[02:05:35] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Wikipe-tan_GothLoli.png [02:05:41] goth wikipedia, goth wikipedia [02:17:45] aww [03:01:14] https://blahaj.sg/ [03:01:16] no way [03:20:12] Would be cool a foss tiktok, why are people using rednote, that's just data stealing by the Chinese government [03:20:55] I remember that the #offtopic was so active [03:24:46] brb rewriting half of Extension:DismissableSiteNotice [03:28:08] data stealing argument kinda falls flat considering what Meta and Google are doing, but I see it equally silly/weird as suddenly trying to migrate to fucking VK [03:28:51] I remember that I wanted a VK acc and my mexican phone number didn't work [03:28:58] But that's wholesome american theft, which american congress can abide. šŸ™ƒ [03:29:37] It's all quite silly, but whatever reasons there were for distrusting tiktok, gotta agree with Emi that jumping to rednote seems... ill-advised. [03:30:33] especially considering how reluctant masses were in "this place is not good, let's try another" cases [03:31:41] Remember during the twitter exodus when like half of the clones were like 'come on over, we're totally not going to do 10x the invasive shit that Twitter was doing' [03:31:59] I forget the exact one, but there was one that caught doing some deeply shady shit and basically collapsed overnight. [03:38:22] TikTok has now been banned [03:38:24] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1330380815502413834/GhoEdmfWEAACuVV.png?ex=678dc52f&is=678c73af&hm=390eb1c48a62442246c270bd949f006746c15833d842d14bc75c73a1efd764a9& [03:39:26] Supposedly, TikTok retains full access to your contacts when it's downloaded on your phone, so it can see all personal data you may have of yourself or others. And you can't disable that. [03:44:07] I remember trying to register in wechat, to get access to some tiny app, and the damn thing required your voice for validation [04:00:29] wow [04:00:41] is hard :( [04:01:11] Bullshit, go to settings and disable that [04:01:33] why(to rewrite) [04:01:38] https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T11209 [04:01:42] Nope - it still does [04:01:48] and i'm here like "hmm, what if we made it still work with no js" [04:01:56] and now i'm making it do a POST request when no js [04:02:02] blahaj ctf yo [04:02:05] yee [04:02:12] Thatā€™s total BS [04:02:17] i'm doing a [04:02:22] Thereā€™s no option in settings? [04:02:30] have you tried it [04:02:34] tried what? [04:02:41] Nope, it's all background [04:03:28] I do agree that TikTok likely poses a genuine national security risk, I just think it's unfortunate that a ban was the chosen route for prevention. [04:04:36] A CTF [04:04:42] ah, nah [04:04:46] That is not how it works [04:04:49] it should not be [04:05:12] [1/2] Any bit of data on your device an app can access should be prompt [04:05:12] [2/2] Ed [04:05:55] I agree, but that's why it's a nat sec risk [04:06:05] You use iOS? [04:06:08] yep [04:06:22] Nothing about contacts in settings? [04:06:45] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/24pdf/24-656_ca7d.pdf [04:07:15] God fuck apple I thought privacy was the one thing they were sometimes good at [04:07:30] Im too tired for this shit [04:07:33] :zuka_disgust: [04:07:44] Sorry, I misread an article earlier it appears. It background accesses other data (not contacts), but when it accesses your contacts + photos, it retains them instead of deleting them like other companies do. [04:07:47] it = tiktok [04:08:20] So yeah, it's a privacy risk for sure [04:09:39] LMAO Lemon8 was banned too šŸ˜‚ [04:11:11] Im too tired for the we need noncommercial and decentralized open web and social media [04:11:20] claire do you wanna do the spiel [04:11:41] hm? [04:12:51] hm? [04:24:10] Bye tiktok for the ones in a US state where is already tomorrow [04:26:00] Thanks for the additional context on this, sketchy retention was something I had heard, but wasn't clear on specifics. [04:34:08] is tiktok banned for yall? [04:34:15] [1/2] been seeing a lotta tweets [04:34:15] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1330394872451956838/image.png?ex=678dd247&is=678c80c7&hm=9a2e0db65dc25021a19352ae85c4a8a2258a090d0fec09c0db696d1b30f314b0& [04:34:59] are you asking for non-us citizens? [04:35:41] no only us [04:36:39] well considering it has been banned on a national level i would assume it would be banned for most if not all americans [04:36:55] it got banned in india like years ago [04:37:02] wouldnt be surprised about any stragglers though [04:37:03] honstly good for us folks here! [04:37:51] depending on how the presidency swings here (philippines) in the next national election we may or may not see similar :kekpossum: [04:38:00] <.guardianx.> Tikitok was one of the more "Free" platforms but man there was a LOT of questionable stuff on it. Youtube rabbit-holes have nothing on falling down a hole on tiktok [04:38:19] (each of the big political factions are very squarely either pro-us or pro-china, with sitting faction being pro-us) [04:38:26] true [04:38:58] whenever i went into tiktok lives rabbitholes it was the closest thing i think ill get to consuming a hallucinogen [04:39:31] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> I wanna say Mastodon tried this and it turned into a VERY questionable, I'll say lightly, space in some places. [04:40:35] <.guardianx.> Any truly free and open platform will be a nightmare to curate / police. [04:41:03] the gays are chill, but there's a lot of drama from time to time [04:41:25] so the gays are not chill? :KEK: [04:41:44] yeah, I got it when using VPN [04:41:54] <.guardianx.> it reminds me of the matrix meme where neo takes the red and blue pill and Morpheus just looks at hime like "Okay guess we are doin this" [04:42:14] i mean when it comes to social media i always think about the public spaces kind of paradigm [04:42:45] Imma use chatgpt to do a tiktok copy (only software no server) with PHP, for the US citizens ā¤ļøšŸ‡ŗšŸ‡ø [04:43:14] [1/2] and in the world outside the internet the ones that are policing public spaces are, well, the police and the government [04:43:14] [2/2] and that really goes with any sort of public space at scale, which is that you need something that will moderate it at scale [04:44:25] <.guardianx.> I think, ultimately, people will go back to forums or group based content creation. maybe an IRC clone / flavour will come back [04:44:44] arent we in one right now :HappySwad: [04:44:53] <.guardianx.> Ehhh kinda [04:45:13] <.guardianx.> Discord controls a lot of things and you are basically playing in comeone elses back yard [04:46:10] [1/2] yeah but its probably the step towards what you're saying [04:46:11] [2/2] when i was still using twitter it was always "why is every community locked in discord" ad nauseum [04:46:48] <.guardianx.> I wish places would stop trying to get me to attach other social platforms to it under the veil of "Ease" [04:47:00] <.guardianx.> "Log in with your facebook account!" [04:47:07] <.guardianx.> link your twitter! [04:47:14] <.guardianx.> tell us your address! [04:47:44] <.guardianx.> I liken it to, "If it would feel creepy coming from an Ex...it's likely creepy" [04:48:03] i can see that [04:55:45] from Windscribe (vpn) server [04:56:02] so it's forced from their side as well [05:15:57] But Mastodon is built around freedom of association, so you can pick or host an instance that wonā€™t federate with that. [05:17:02] Thatā€™s most of the web these days [05:17:21] I have a video link related for this ill send in the morning [05:18:19] I use Mastodon as my main microblogging social and really my only Social Media off of discord [05:18:44] The Fediverse is far from perfect but it has my respect, and I wouldnā€™t really chose anything else [05:19:18] yeah, honestly, most of my problems are from the mentally ill trans women /lh [05:19:38] i just realised how discriminatory that looks after writing it oh my god [05:20:23] would like to clarify claire is transgender so probably not transphobic [05:20:32] For everyone else [05:20:37] mhm [05:21:11] https://files.catbox.moe/6qqu36.png [07:23:35] yes [07:24:16] I honestly donā€™t get the whole ā€œoh masto is full or horrible peopleā€ thing because I havenā€™t encountered a single thing of that sort [07:24:26] like [07:24:53] either those people donā€™t know anything about fedi or they use instances with absolutely horrible blocklists [08:02:44] speaking of fediverse things [08:03:14] whatā€™s peopleā€™s opinion on the sort of forced move of c/196 to lemmy.world, I dislike it IMO [09:07:32] anyone remember the magic word to see the number of miraheze wikis that have installed an extension [09:32:45] [1/2] pogchamp [09:32:46] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1330469993359343720/jzWc97OVMA.gif?ex=678e183d&is=678cc6bd&hm=f5fbbb52e5719919a21b76230c45d48cfb44a3e720b24d93b57cdbaad65a8b7f& [10:13:45] [1/3] There isn't a social media platform that doesn't attract rebellious and hateful types that want to stir up toxicity. [10:13:45] [2/3] BlueSky is rather new, (A Twitter like platform) and seems to be doing okay for now, but there have already been seen a few of those loonies. [10:13:46] [3/3] Society has been rotten for a long time, and that can be seen as an effect of said society. [11:59:54] [1/3] ``` [11:59:55] [2/3] {{NUMBEROFWIKISUSINGEXTENSION: extension_name_in_lowercase}} [11:59:55] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/NUMBEROFWIKISUSINGEXTENSION:Template:_extension_name_in_lowercase [11:59:55] [3/3] ``` [12:08:03] Ah yes [12:08:15] Wonder if theres a way to fetch that to the static site [12:08:21] via js [12:08:23] probably [12:15:42] [1/2] -# by that i mean i also wish my problems were from mentally ill tgirls [12:15:42] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1330510998779596821/images.png?ex=678e3e6d&is=678ceced&hm=ed08c0a4eed8ada71c23380f1f60d27d08acdb3a5c9856514b8b143b6fde7a27& [12:15:58] lmao [13:47:04] ||https://youtu.be/Ppa-LULpJ1s?si=d5qr_abKpHuckgk4|| [13:58:39] [1/4] Bad gateway [13:58:39] [2/4] The web server reported a bad gateway error. [13:58:39] [3/4] Ray ID: 90475592ce07930a Your IP address: - - - - Error reference number: 502 Cloudflare Location: Copenhagen [13:58:40] [4/4] That was not expected šŸ˜› [16:31:43] Wow [16:31:51] I slept till 11:30 [17:07:41] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> [1/3] Oh yeah, I think thats kinda the point I'm trying to make not all that well (hehe), there is a slider where you can have "Freedom" on a platform or app or whatever but it comes at a social perception cost of sorts (towards the platform or people that use it.) because eventually someone will do something that others don't like with that freedom OR the platform [17:07:41] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> [2/3] will become associated with dark things. [17:07:41] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> [3/3] I don't think locally hosted decentralized products are going away any time soon, at least I hope not. Part of me hopes more government crackdowns happen and force people away from the comfort apps and into making their own things, but the pessimist in me says that all things eventually turn into systems of control. [17:07:55] Lazy [17:08:33] I was home last 1 AM from NYC [17:08:44] Okay fair [17:09:22] Is past noon still breakfast [17:10:15] Brunch [17:10:24] Eh good enough [17:10:50] Iā€™m gonna go finish my Devilā€™s Food cheesecake from Juniors [17:16:13] there's also freedom... in line with your beliefs [17:16:40] much is decided by how groups respond when you push their buttons [17:16:56] Freedom? In the US? [17:16:57] _looks at TikTok_ [17:19:20] I'm very quick to tell you it's funny hypocrisy coming from the US government considering how happy they are to molest the data of their own citizens let alone international users, or target people with 'unsavory' beliefs [17:19:53] opposition to american imperialism being the usual historical net they cast [17:28:31] The TikTok issue is complex [17:28:53] <.guardianx., replying to originalauthority> [1/2] I mean the ironic part to me is that the rest of the world has similar, if not greater, freedoms but the US being so vocal about their freedoms and then having limits on those freedoms casts a very strange light on freedoms in-general. [17:28:53] <.guardianx., replying to originalauthority> [2/2] The irony isn't lost on people in the US either I would add. [17:32:43] the US is hardly the worst on the market for that but it can take a lot of pages out of europe to be a whole lot better [17:34:23] My 2 main issues with the TikTok ban is none of the rest of the world seem to deem it such a serious risk [17:34:32] And what about every other Chinese company [17:34:34] Where's the line [17:34:44] <.guardianx., replying to rhinosf1> Part of me wants the korean internet rules lightly applied. No social media / internet presence without proof of being an adult or, maybe tied to an adult / guardian. [17:35:13] <.guardianx.> thats some hot bigbrother level garbage though [17:35:38] At lot of the world are considering varying levels of age protection [17:35:47] Australia has the strictest laws coming [17:35:56] But the UK is for adult sites [17:36:11] <.guardianx.> I don't understand parents that let their kids social media personally. Like I know parents that didn't let their kids get the covid vaccine that let their kids social media...So strange [17:36:28] That wouldnt solve the TikTok problem though [17:36:53] We've grown through a time where the internet has grown quick [17:37:03] <.guardianx.> Was there even a foundational level for the TT problem? [17:37:09] <.guardianx.> or was it a collection of things [17:37:27] for a long time I'd been very 'parents just need to be more responsible' but I've weened on that seeing how frankly moronic parents can be, even beyond technology; it's not necessarily good to leave it up to them at least entirely which frustrates me because that opens the door to other more meddling steps (the only other parties are government or businesses...) [17:37:32] If you compare computers when @pixldev, our baby in the channel started high school, to me to an old man like @.labster there's a huge difference [17:37:56] It's noticeable massively to me the difference between current kids and when I was one [17:38:01] Never mind anyone actually old [17:38:13] Yes, there's foundation there [17:38:15] I would probably rather be in total opposition to the world trend of verification laws than give in to steps which will probably be overreach though [17:38:19] But there's a few big questions [17:39:30] <.guardianx., replying to rhinosf1> I heard a lot of "things" but I don't wanna repeat some of them, I just wonder how much of what I heard was assumptions vs valid [17:40:04] The argument is that china could use the data TikTok holds to spy on US citizens [17:40:11] And that the risk is too significant [17:40:31] <.guardianx.> Ehh idiots posted geolocs to facebook and we still have facebook [17:40:32] Which makes me think: 1) what about citizens of every other western country? [17:40:49] 2) what about any other company in any less than friendly nation [17:41:08] US don't care about the risk of the US spying on Americans [17:41:11] when parents don't allow the kids will find the other ways or substitutes (cough fandom discussions cough) [17:41:16] Facebook's Americans [17:41:26] more specifically, how about the US doing the exact same thing to US and non US citizens [17:41:50] I'm not bothered about that as much [17:41:53] or in absence of that doing the obvious loophole of just buying all the data [17:41:59] But if TikTok is such a threat to the UK [17:42:06] Why not UK or EU [17:42:16] They ain't coming up with similar ideas to my knowledge [17:42:16] that is on them to individually decide [17:42:18] <.guardianx., replying to rhinosf1> I understand that but my point is stupid people will stupid no matter the platform. [17:42:31] The security risk is less though [17:42:35] I got Internet access at 17 because broke, and while it didn't stop me from making some mistaked the first few years, I kind of glad I didn't have it all during my teenagehood [17:42:44] It's about what the Chinese could extract from ByteDance's servers [17:42:52] it is pretty funny that the country of free speech is the first to ban before UK which has a horrible record digitally or the EU [17:43:00] Ye but surely they would if the risk was there [17:43:15] they might disagree about that, or the extent to which it is a threat [17:43:29] to me that's not a really big point, they just go about it differently [17:44:33] Eh it does challenge the reasoning behind the ban a bit [17:44:46] It's a fairly unprecedented action [17:44:58] It's going to be interesting to see what happens next [17:45:29] Social Media for kids keep shutting down [17:46:05] I didn't have a phone until I was 10 [17:46:12] And that phone didn't run Facebook [17:46:20] It's battery lasted about 3 text messages [17:46:28] It really was for emergency purposes only [17:46:31] I was an ipad kid [17:47:04] That phone was seriously dodgy [17:47:12] Damn [17:47:21] I've had social media since I was 13 [17:47:41] Tech was still quite new [17:48:04] I'm on the very backend of the era where phones and computers become everywhere [17:48:29] <.guardianx., replying to ghaztliousmoths> [1/2] Anything aimed directly towards kids is a "Dangerous" thing IMHO. [17:48:30] <.guardianx., replying to ghaztliousmoths> [2/2] Sure, it doesn't HAVE to be dangerous and it usually doesn't START as dangerous, but when you mix kids with anything you get creepers that try to worm their way into it and eventually it just becomes a place that shouldn't cater to kids anymore. [17:48:31] Hmp [17:48:31] The iPhone is younger than me [17:48:45] Are you younger than the iPhone? [17:49:58] <.guardianx.> A lot falls to the old as heck phrase "The road to hell is paved with good intentions" [17:50:14] Creepers are everywhere. The internet only makes it easier for them to reach you. [17:50:32] [1/3] Yea [17:50:32] [2/3] It just sucks for kids [17:50:32] [3/3] I'm glad I lived in a time were mmos were at their peak [17:52:15] Spent my childhood being constantly advertised to in Bin Weevils [17:52:26] This is true [17:52:47] I remember that [17:53:06] <.guardianx., replying to rhinosf1> Grouping makes it even easier. It's a 100% "that sucks" situation where you want people to experience things but you end up with a "this is why we can't have nice things" situation pretty quick. [17:53:32] Age verification is not the way though IMO [17:53:54] It comprises the privacy and animosity of kids and adults [17:54:16] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> Yeah, honestly I don't think there is a solution that wouldn't cross very quickly into a state monitored "solution" [17:54:16] Okay [17:54:27] How the fuck do you spell it [17:54:32] more of it, I expect. Rarely will something like this be backed down from, at most it will be temporarily shelved and reintroduced later with less pushback [17:54:40] Anomitity [17:54:41] No [17:54:42] God [17:54:48] <.guardianx.> an non nymity [17:54:50] <.guardianx.> ? [17:54:53] someone, in this case the US, boldly steps up to do the thing, and the world will watch what it takes to do more of that thing [17:54:54] I like how @pixldev ignored my are you younger than the iPhone? [17:55:19] <.guardianx.> anonymity [17:55:25] No xommen [17:55:31] thank you [17:55:34] I hate spelling [17:55:43] Spelling sucks [17:55:44] Even STT didnā€™t understand me PMAO [17:56:07] <.guardianx., replying to pixldev> Hooked on phonics kid here...man I can't believe parents back then trusted that [17:56:15] That's probably a good bet [17:57:11] <.guardianx.> I mean, since the US did it, you know there will be lawsuits soon LOL [17:57:52] There's lawsuits in the US about most things [17:58:53] <.guardianx.> the hot coffee thing was the best example of Lawsuits and marketing to paint perception ever >< [17:59:09] <.guardianx.> two of my least favourite professions... [18:00:03] <.guardianx.> they gaslit an entire generation so hard that people legit think, to this day, that the lady that sued over "hot coffee" was asking for millions of dollars. [18:00:17] Ye that's actually got more to it [18:00:29] There's a video from the guy whose suing Honey about that [18:01:07] https://youtu.be/s_jaU5V9FUg?si=YyrgIzau5wrUmyzr [18:03:41] It's not only apps. It's allso Chinese people wanting to work in vital organisations [18:03:58] Like ASML (chip making machines) [18:04:02] Hi everyone, hope you're all doing well šŸ™‚ [18:04:19] The Chinese do really anything to get people inside [18:04:23] Yup [18:04:28] Possibly [18:04:44] Doing okay here in Scandinavia [18:04:58] :sw [18:05:09] Youā€™re in Scandinavia? [18:05:30] I had bought this for several years, mcdonalds played their cards perfectly there [18:06:42] Denmark, Norway, Sweden [18:11:40] Resistance is futile, we are all over the world [18:21:36] <.labster, replying to rhinosf1> https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/17/tech/eu-tiktok-investigation-romanian-election-intl/index.html [18:22:29] oh yeah, remember the news [18:22:33] about this guy [18:22:49] like dude suddenly out of nowhere got popular [18:23:04] <.labster> His campaign did really well for spending $0 [18:24:20] That is the problem when you don't change with the times [18:25:29] Like those TV priests that beg for money, instead of going door to door with collection boxes. [18:26:07] You reach the masses in one go [18:26:30] Some churches use YouTube too. [18:27:12] When politicians use popular platforms like Tiktok, instagram, facebook, etc. they have more people they can reach [18:27:31] <.labster> I feel like politicians have understood the power of mass media since the Nazis came to power. [18:28:44] Most still use the dry content: "This is me, this is my goal" - (at least in most countries I think. [18:29:50] They often keep it broad to draw as many as they can, while some focus on 1 point only that is keeping most people occupied. [18:31:15] But I stay neutral on politics. So I'm not going into details [18:35:04] Apparently tiktok is becoming available again to us users [18:35:45] pfff [18:35:48] the timing [18:44:00] The funnier thing is that TikTok is banned in mainline china [18:44:32] (Notwithstanding, Trump has promised to sign an executive order and TikTok is now back up in America lol) [18:45:21] there's just china exclusive version of tt [18:46:09] Are they stupid [18:46:14] Rhetorical of course [20:10:28] o rly? [20:13:57] https://tenor.com/view/yes-very-sad-anyway-loki-sad-loki-gif-22079369 [20:19:02] I bet they probe into Tiktok and found 0 serious issues about "national security" [20:19:58] There's definitely an issue there [20:20:10] How big of one and what to do about it is a bigger debate [20:20:56] The best thing I can think of about China is that they have soft power, not like having citizen data [20:21:37] A foreign, not amazingly friendly, country having access to significant amounts of data about your population is definitely a risk [20:21:48] It also does allow for manipulation [20:21:55] both of them are genuine issues [20:22:05] yea [20:22:52] Exactly what the correct way of dealing with emerging issues of the internet and its mass adoption are probably something we should have considered a bit ago [20:23:08] But as I said earlier, the internet has moved extremely quickly [20:23:18] I'm not that old and I'm still younger than the iPhone [20:23:21] rhinos I need input from a British person [20:23:42] Google is failing me [20:23:48] My primary school (up to age 11 for you Americans) only had 1 IT tech that visited once every 2 weeks [20:23:54] And a single printer for students [20:24:09] Most of the staff didn't know the first thing about computers [20:24:17] They asked me and my mates to teach a focus week once [20:24:24] Go for it [20:24:54] What are the rights and obligations of citizens in the UK. Because the lists Iā€™m finding seem to be confusing citizens with people in general [20:25:04] Unless free speech is Brits only there [20:25:46] And following the law is optional for non British people :AwesomeSmiley: [20:26:10] It's called freedom of expression and it comes from the European convention on human rights [20:28:08] But there's no absolute right to freedom of speech like the US [20:28:21] Which applies to all humans [20:28:37] Bold of you to assume we have that just because itā€™s written on some old paper /j [20:28:57] Yes [20:29:30] The requirements im working through (for Boy Scouts) state citizens, hence why I ask [20:30:49] What does it actually say [20:32:13] Heh, we don't have an old paper that works as a constitution [20:32:46] ā€œDiscuss the similarities and differences between the rights duties and obligations of US citizens and the citizens of two other countriesā€ [20:33:08] Right [20:33:15] Wtf you studying? [20:33:32] That could be a fucking masters paper [20:33:40] Also TIL that Portuguese citizens who permanently live in Brazil have the same rights as Brazilian citizens [20:33:43] Uuuh [20:33:48] Citizenship in the World merit badge [20:33:54] Right [20:34:08] Where did scouts get that for a merit badge [20:34:30] Bloody hell [20:35:00] idk [20:35:22] but its an eagle requirement badge and i need one more to rank up soooo [20:35:25] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-the-world/ [20:36:48] Bloody hell [20:37:04] Genuinely what planet are they on @pixldev [20:37:14] America. [20:37:40] Why [20:38:23] Cause I'm paying people Ā£50k a year to do number 3 [20:38:55] 7 looks normal [20:39:07] And 1 [20:39:22] The rest of that is not high school level [20:39:32] @originalauthority I saw you typing, please go on [20:40:52] So thatā€™s why child labor was a thing [20:41:20] (I was just gonna say that cloudflare blog wowch) [20:41:48] Cloudflare's blogs are great [20:42:04] @originalauthority please do help me though here [20:42:06] When my scoutmaster was looking over the requirements after recommending me to do this badge he said ā€œ[blah blah blah] visit the us state website youā€™ve probably hacked it alreadyā€ which i found hilarious [20:42:22] I need whatever he's drinking [20:42:27] This looks a lot like stuff I studied in A Level Geography and parts of my degree lol [20:42:46] Exactly, that could like an international politics degree [20:43:03] What was your degree [20:43:20] My undergrad was in Urban Studies [20:43:27] Sounds so boring but was actually pretty fun [20:43:39] There are other citizenship badges too [20:43:48] But notwithstanding, that question seems flawed -- what obligations is it taking about? [20:43:53] if you wanna see if those are any less advanced [20:44:02] _nobody is really obligated to do anything_ [20:44:03] im also confused ngl [20:44:19] I interpreted obligations as MUST and duty as SHOULD [20:44:30] In the US, voting is a right and a duty [20:44:40] but in Brazil, voting is also an obligation [20:44:49] (for citizens 18-70) [20:45:12] Jury Duty and Military service too id call obligatory [20:45:27] Military service isn't an obligation in most countries [20:45:28] i mean this is going to be a discussion not just paperwork [20:45:28] I guess you could cite that as a difference then? That its not a requirement to vote in England _although frowned upon if you dont_, whereas in Brazil its mandatory [20:45:37] Nor do I think it should be [20:45:48] so i dont need to get each and every detail right [20:45:53] Real [20:46:03] Is jury duty a thing there [20:46:03] I for one would not go to war for this shit hole of a country [20:46:09] Yes [20:46:34] Is there any fucking difference in righrs of citizens between the US and UK [20:46:44] @originalauthority I have no idea why the conservatives tried the national service plan beyond a shock policy [20:46:49] Yes [20:46:50] It was a daft idea [20:47:03] You cant shoot someone in ur back garden in the UK and get away with it [20:47:18] i dont think thats a right [20:47:29] The right to bare arms? [20:47:33] Not a thing in england [20:47:37] Oh [20:47:40] I mean if that's your opinion, I wouldn't want you in the service. You're a liability. [20:47:52] Dang [20:48:06] Call of Duty would say otherwise but i digress [20:48:11] _a joke, obviously_ [20:48:14] If you wave a gun around here, you're getting met by an armed response team [20:48:23] That you will not want to mess with [20:48:44] They're very friendly though if you're polite to them [20:49:12] I've asked armed police for directions before [20:49:52] In the US the armed part is implied [20:50:12] the US has a bit of an issue of police continually getting closer to soliders [20:50:16] Our armed police are actually trained to use a weapon [20:50:18] And rare [20:50:24] Unless you're at an airport [20:50:32] Or live in a military city like me [20:50:35] Or parts of London [20:50:38] Important things [20:51:28] In Brazil i know federal military and civil police are three different things but i dont recall the details [20:51:40] anyways i may just move to the next part of this [20:51:42] [1/4] I guess you could maybe touch on the following as a start [20:51:43] [2/4] - right to bear arms [20:51:43] [3/4] - right to privacy (differences between how the US derives these from the constitution, whereas in UK/EU most come from GDPR and other places like that) [20:51:43] [4/4] - In the UK everyone has a right to free healthcare at the point of use, versuses america [20:51:56] NSA <3 [20:52:31] The approach to armed policing in both countries is also massively different [20:52:32] Does the GDPR apply to all people or citizens? I feel that distinction is holding back a lot here [20:52:35] Potentially stuff about protesting too -- in the US protesting is a given right but in the UK we still have it, but Councils can heavily restrict it and impose conditions on protesting if they feel its disruptive [20:52:40] i may chose to ignore the citizenship part nfl [20:52:55] In what sense? [20:52:57] Globally? [20:52:58] Like London this weekend if you want a current event [20:53:18] Like, it applies to people living in the EU, not only registered citizens [20:54:47] (Also we dont have a pledge of allegiance or that bullshit which I guess you could touch on, potentially differences between how people swear allegiance to the crown/constitution) idk that question is really vague lol [20:55:11] Erm, idk about that one [20:55:18] I love saying an oath of eternal servitude at school every single day [20:55:21] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2016/679/article/3 [20:55:55] So anyone in the UK [20:56:09] whats this convo about? [20:56:25] Unless you run a multi million pound company then GDPR doesnt apply šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø [20:56:25] It applies to any controlling or processing of data in the UK/EU or that of someone in the UK/EU [20:56:32] My apparently college level requirements for a Boy Scout merit badge [20:56:59] So GDPR would apply to data stored by a UK company of a non UK person [20:57:03] Huh [20:57:20] Or any UK person's data by anyone [20:57:42] A lot of things don't apply with money [20:58:36] im just saying fuck it to the citizenship part lol [20:58:45] @pixldev question, would you actually go up to like a police officer in America and ask for help if you needed it? [20:58:47] these are good to discuss though ty [20:58:54] Yeah [20:58:58] Like me asking an armed police officer for directions [20:59:13] Basically all officers carry guns these days iirc [20:59:22] In the US ye [20:59:23] If im lost i probably would [20:59:38] A lot round here do because lots of military here [20:59:42] But would be less common having GPS [20:59:45] I would just use google maps personally but each to their own! [20:59:55] few weeks ago me and my dad did that in Brazil [21:00:00] they were civil police iirc [21:00:08] i donā€™t remember if they were armed [21:00:11] they were nice [21:00:22] Google maps was not an option for the record [21:00:50] as an american I would ask locally, but then, it's a small time police group that seems to be mostly decent eggs [21:01:01] the problem is that the variation is comically extreme depending on where [21:01:10] I donā€™t really ever see them standing on the street [21:01:23] same [21:01:25] always in their cars and speeding past red lights [21:01:25] sitting in a car would usually bit it, yeah [21:01:32] Mhm [21:01:43] I see police everytime I go to the train station [21:01:51] speeding's the big one around here, they'll break it and only enforce it in special areas or extreme cases [21:02:12] locally, we have only hired private security officers in our train stations [21:02:16] in the good parts of town [21:02:17] You see we have visible police here too [21:02:31] They gotta catch the donut shop before it closes [21:02:44] Last 2 times I've spoke to the police they've been their naturally [21:03:02] See for me its too suburban for that. The local train station is usually pretty empty [21:03:14] Once was chance, they were responding to a car accident like 30s walk away [21:03:26] Once they were on foot patrol on the beach [21:03:27] Im gonna move on to the next parts of the requirements and get back to rights and stuff later [21:03:44] Conversely in england the stations are usually pretty busy but empty of trains šŸ˜Ŗ [21:03:48] Commuter rail is usually empty for me too, yeah, but the city train is usually full [21:04:02] I told them they might want to go walk in a certain direction and move a drunk on [21:04:13] Iā€™ve never seen the commuter rail station with more than maybe 3 people on the platform [21:04:28] does the tiktok ban count as a world event [21:04:38] I'd find it notable [21:04:40] Ye you don't get trains actually show [21:04:49] Quite a significant one [21:04:50] because it actually is surprisingly good as a topic for requirement 3 [21:05:07] gonna be so real rn: no [21:05:14] but i donā€™t know the context in which youā€™re asking [21:05:16] > (a) Pick a current world event. In relation to this current event, discuss with your counselor how a country's national interest and its relationship with other countries might affect areas such as its security, its economy, its values, and the health of its citizens. [21:05:21] why not, besides 'tiktok is dumb' lines of reason [21:05:27] Read the bloody requirements then [21:05:47] Security & Values are a key part of the TikTok issue [21:06:17] From a balancing security with someone's rights and freedoms, it's a very significant event and debate [21:06:18] Economy somewhat. Huge amounts of American companies sent cash to china for advertising on TY [21:06:23] Hmh? [21:06:41] it touches on quite a few things, more in terms of the precedence it sets [21:06:46] The only one I'd question is health [21:06:49] [1/4] couple reasons: [21:06:49] [2/4] 1. TikTok isnā€™t the only form of social media. Itā€™s not as if all social media was shut off, just one platform that has quite viable alternatives. [21:06:50] [3/4] 2. The world didnā€™t ban TikTok ā€” one country did. Itā€™s not a global event that occurred. [21:06:50] [4/4] 3. There are no clear economic or societal impacts. [21:07:18] in my opinion of course [21:07:24] You are really uneducated [21:07:39] 2) as pointed out earlier, yes they are considering it [21:07:51] There are 7 million americans who derive their livelihood from TikTok [21:08:15] [1/3] 1. a top social media company comprising of a double digit portion of social media use at least, easily named among top countries [21:08:15] [2/3] 2. the country with the most influence on internet affairs is a little different from whereverthehellistan [21:08:16] [3/3] 3. significant impacts on discussions for censorship, restriction of platforms, impacts on a tool a great many people use, and other aspects [21:08:17] 3) it has significant societal impact. The banning of media based on the country it originates from on the balance of security is a huge debate [21:08:27] And many people do earn from it [21:08:28] thats not the wording id use.. [21:08:34] 'you are really uneducated' is phrasing I'd steer back from but I would say that is a poor take [21:08:50] yeah, that felt unnecessary to say [21:09:00] it is only fair given what's been called for CoC lately to remark that calling uneducated bald faced isn't in spirit of CoC either [21:09:18] There's been significant debate in this channel today about that ban and the impacts of it [21:09:38] Hey, how are you people? [21:09:42] Also about the whole scouts ask anyway [21:09:45] brandon stepped in without that context, which admittedly wasn't hard to gather [21:10:04] Ye I found the stepping in completely without context annoying [21:10:10] hm? [21:10:13] Maybe harsh to say it came across as uneducated [21:10:16] What about the propaganda for Trump treated like a "hero" wasn't mentioned, though idk if it matters [21:10:26] Just on the pure basis of defining a "world event" - you can't define one country's ban of a platform as a world event. [21:10:28] The fact that the task they gave you could form a degree paper [21:10:36] You absolutely can [21:10:44] Could be better, learned once more the joy of having neighbours.. [21:10:50] Because the actions of America can have huge impacts [21:11:12] it is an event involving one of the largest platforms in the world in the country with the single largest impact on global internet [21:11:32] it may have occurred in america but the ramifications are international [21:11:32] Single largest impact on a lot of things in the world [21:11:38] Definitely western world [21:12:06] But when you compare the TikTok ban to other commonly regarded world events, which ones would you say are smaller than TikTok? [21:12:30] 9/11, Challenger, Brexit, Russia-Ukraine, Gaza [21:12:35] you're going to have to specify because a lot happens on world scale, it is not that it has to completely affect the lives of everyone around [21:12:36] Each event has its own impacts in its own areas [21:12:44] For varying lengths of time [21:12:54] but by your logic gaza's a middle east thing, brexit is a britain thing, 9/11 was an america thing [21:13:10] But there are clear world impacts from all of them [21:13:12] in each case as well as this one their impact was observed in knockoff effects [21:13:23] If you were earning your livelihood of TikTok, it will have a lot more significant impact on your socioeconomic state than 9/11 [21:13:32] the knockoff effects are yet to be set in this case, as they were not quite set for all the others you mentioned [21:13:33] Cause there's a good chance you weren't born for 9/11 [21:13:55] So you won't feel the impacts that had in every case [21:14:19] I wasn't, but it's shaped the way global security operates today [21:14:37] For me, Brexit had a much larger impact than the TikTok ban because I don't even have a TikTok account [21:14:38] it shaped the way america responded to things which in turn influenced other countries [21:14:47] You don't have that comparison though [21:14:49] Neither do I [21:14:57] so take a look at the fact that the US is setting a precedent for blocking extremely massive websites [21:14:58] I wasn't born so I never travelled before 9/11 [21:15:02] That's a fair point - at this time I wouldn't consider TikTok a world event. If there later become clear impacts from the ban (or lack thereof), then I would. [21:15:17] that is a narrow look that is not considering consequence [21:15:24] Them impacts are something we've got to watch for [21:15:27] it does not take a lot to observe the possible ramifications [21:15:32] If we want to discuss the merits of the ban, I'd say it's justified (but that's a different topic) [21:15:38] it is [21:15:46] I think there's absolutely basis behind the ban [21:15:56] my issue is less the act of ban as much as its hypocrisy [21:16:01] It's a very bold move to ban such a large site on national security grounds [21:16:06] but nonethless it will be used to justify interventions in the future [21:16:15] Based on the country it originated from [21:16:47] The law doesn't outright ban the site though, there are alternatives to avoid the ban [21:16:59] The fact the Supreme Court has upheld the ban, sets a precedent about how much your rights and freedoms can be balanced with security [21:17:06] That's true [21:17:23] The fact that TikTok would prefer to shut down operations with 170 million users and billions in revenue rather than divest says a lot about the true influence over ByteDance. [21:17:35] Quite possibly yes [21:18:01] EVIDENTLY [21:18:08] The way I read the SCOTUS opinion was preventing foreign influences > 1st amendment rights for TikTok (which doesn't have 1st amendment rights anyway) [21:18:32] Personally, I think the ban should trigger quite a debate about security and privacy in the modern world [21:18:44] We need a lot of those [21:18:51] The internet has moved very quickly [21:18:57] How are folks feeling about the tone and content of this conversation? Remaining civil and free to continue without name-calling? [21:19:13] Completely good so far with it šŸ‘ [21:19:21] Productive and civil [21:19:21] I'm going for a shower soon [21:19:28] But fine with it [21:19:46] curious your thoughts here @raidarr? [21:20:00] As I said earlier, I'm older than the iPhone, now most people have phones with them constantly [21:20:17] Cool, checking in as I saw this going a mile a minute. [21:20:17] The kind of reach for everyone has grown a lot [21:20:25] I agree for sure [21:20:35] I'm curious if other countries will ban TikTok now too, though [21:20:43] (UK is who I'm looking at) [21:20:52] I would be surprised if others didn't follow [21:21:00] Otherwise it kind of undermines the US [21:21:11] In my opinion [21:21:26] I actually doubt the TikTok ban ends up being upheld [21:21:33] I have not examined closely enough, I imagine they could do this out of pride or principle (least likely), if they could not gain from revenue in the divested company, or indeed if they just wanted to retain control. But I am reluctant to read extra into it [21:22:11] The actions of the next administration are going to be fairly unpredictable [21:22:33] Trump did initially agree with the ban [21:22:40] I agree [21:22:44] But he seems to have changed his mind [21:23:02] He realized TikTok has extraordinary benefits for the election, heh [21:23:11] <.labster, replying to brandon.wm> The ban was already upheld by the court, just unlikely for the law to be enforced under Trump. [21:23:38] That's what I mean, Trump can direct the DOJ to ignore the law and not fine companies for it [21:23:52] Which is what I think is likely to happen [21:24:06] That's also probably unconstitutional, but I digress [21:24:08] how did this start with a fucking merit badhe [21:24:34] Whoever gave you this assignment is dumb for asking this specific question [21:24:50] No [21:24:52] The answer is a global debate [21:25:02] The requirements are standard across BSA [21:25:08] Seriously? [21:25:13] šŸ¤¦ā€ā™‚ļø [21:25:17] Even worse [21:25:22] My Scoutmaster recommended me this badge as itā€™s topics im interested in [21:25:25] which is true [21:25:52] I mean, I probably couldn't answer this without a lot of pages [21:25:58] Comparing international and national law, world organizations, constitutional and non constitutional governments [21:26:19] hell yes [21:26:28] Right - there's so many aspects to this, I don't even understand how you dissect it all in a short essay [21:26:42] Note this isnā€™t a writing assignment explicitly [21:27:01] You discuss this with a counselor [21:27:20] Im writing notes on the worksheet to have them ready to discuss [21:27:31] [1/3] I doubt the UK would; mostly thinking about how elections work here. [21:27:31] [2/3] In the UK its the most votes that wins, which means to be successful you're looking to piss off the least amount of people. [21:27:31] [3/3] In the US, you only need to stay on the right side of the bigger states šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø [21:27:33] Heh @rhinosf1 I'm looking forward to the eventual petition before SCOTUS, there likely will be one if Trump directs the DOJ to ignore the law (can a President ignore a SCOTUS ruling?) [21:28:11] Also conversely we don't have congress that can dictate things like America does [21:28:12] That's true, yeah. But the UK has also been far stricter on individual rights than the US has been [21:28:50] Meh I guess yeah [21:29:48] <.labster, replying to brandon.wm> John Marshall has made his decision; now let him enforce it! -- apocryphal Andrew Jackson [21:30:43] But Iā€™m confused what would happen now ā€” the Supreme Court has given Presidents immunity during their term for official acts, which this is [21:30:45] Notwithstanding, I bet Mark Lizardberg was rubbing his hands together thinking everyone would flock to instagram, hah [21:31:17] Instagram also rolled out ANOTHER ugly update, thanks zucc [21:31:29] Does that mean Presidents are now exempt from SCOTUS, removing a critical part of checks and balances? [21:31:42] Yeah they fucked the aspect ratio on profiles didnt they? [21:31:57] And they left aligned everything in the profile header. Meta never heard of flex box?! [21:32:32] That's another very complex question [21:33:09] square previews no more too, end of an era [21:33:10] Trump is already a convicted felon so just add it to the list [21:33:47] This is the biggest question imo [21:33:48] How effectives the checks and balances that the US system has for executive power and the limits of executive power will probably be tested [21:33:54] of all platforms going shit I feel bad for tumblr and insta the most [21:34:06] @pixldev because your scouts discussion could be a masters paper [21:34:19] It's not an easy discussion [21:34:48] Be back in a bit, going to pick up fam from the airport [21:35:51] @pixldev I'm genuinely not sure that scouts badge should be aimed at someone your age [21:35:57] Is there a level below? [21:36:28] I hope you've learnt something from this debate though [21:40:48] Welp im a creature of pure spite so im gonna fucking do it [21:41:00] Theres not really levels [21:41:16] the Citizen badges are eagle required though [21:41:24] Fair [21:41:28] I can't question that [21:41:30] kinda nice that they're going the trouble of getting people to think about the big stuff without relegating it to masters [21:41:41] Do you want to see the other ones lol [21:41:41] I have no idea what any of that means mate [21:41:46] Sure [21:41:58] Ye it's very nice the discussions are being had [21:42:05] i mean I finished cit in the nation in one sit down with my counselor [21:42:42] [1/3] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-society/ [21:42:43] [2/3] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-nation/ [21:42:43] [3/3] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-community/ [21:42:55] society* [21:44:59] Only the top link works for me [21:45:37] yeah the others are broke [21:45:54] Found it searching [21:46:00] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-the-nation/ [21:46:14] Weird [21:46:59] @pixldev they seem fine [21:47:22] Why is the in the world so complex compared to the others [21:47:28] Hm [21:47:38] Also what's this eagle required thing @pixldev [21:48:21] To reach eagle, the most prestigious rank, you need all the eagle required (silver bordered) badges and a number of non eagles [21:48:45] Oh right [21:48:51] So it's a rank [21:49:00] you also need X amount to rank up to star and life [21:49:06] the two before [21:49:49] I have all the non eagle i need [21:50:03] and i need one more eagle badge to rank up to star [21:50:13] Aka this one [21:51:28] I have cit in the community almost done but i need volunteer hours for that one [21:51:35] sadly i dont think MH counts [21:52:16] <_arawynn> I'd say try it [21:53:11] I love Tom's dig at Slough in https://youtu.be/8-evKtoPN-8?si=3w1w43tuDu2yRM_E [21:53:17] Why not [21:53:21] Eh, I interpreted it as local community [21:53:28] ie animal shelter, library [21:53:29] Let me read it [21:53:35] the badges are built around scopes [21:53:44] the community, society, nation, world [21:54:04] https://www.scouting.org/merit-badges/citizenship-in-the-community/ [21:54:08] I could ask [21:54:11] > Attend an in-person meeting of your city, town, or county council or school board, local court session; OR another state or local governmental meeting approved in advance by your counselor. [21:54:15] That's a really good idea [21:54:18] Its uo to the counselor [21:54:24] Although it's probably on YouTube [21:54:27] done that twice [21:54:29] it is [21:54:33] but we went in person [21:55:04] Ye it's got to be funded by local taxes [21:55:12] Sad [21:55:31] What did you think? [21:55:57] I'm actually quite impressed about how much effort they are putting into helping young people get involved in community and government [21:56:26] It was cool [21:56:37] when i went they were discussing affordable housing iirc [21:56:46] I love these looks at the system [21:57:07] we had a councilwomen come in near the end of last year for a troop QnA [21:57:16] was also productive [21:59:52] Scouting is interesting like that [22:00:43] Im curious how the scouting movement in the UK does [22:00:44] Personally, some level of understanding should be part of standard education [22:01:27] Education sadly doesn't really teach you life skills [22:01:47] Nor any knowledge of how things work in government and stuff about your local community [22:02:03] We got scouting from the UK [22:02:44] I know nothing about scouts [22:02:51] I did my bronze and silver DofE though [22:03:00] That got me into volunteering at martial arts [22:03:04] Which was awesome [22:04:45] What martial art [22:04:55] I taught Karate [22:05:11] I trained in both Karate, Kickboxing and 2 weapons @pixldev [22:05:20] I used to help in classes for Taekwondo years ago [22:05:23] not anymore [22:05:28] no time among other things [22:06:07] a friend of mine in my MA school just become a junior instructor [22:06:11] well she was before [22:06:15] next level now [22:06:27] Itā€™s actually a paid job now [22:06:40] ive been considering doing the leadership program [22:06:46] I wonder how many certified instructors we have now [22:06:55] I was never a CI, just a volunteer [22:07:37] @pixldev I found it really rewarding [22:08:27] I do find it scary that some of the kids I've taught martial arts when they were seven will take some of their GCSEs this year [22:08:51] The kids that were 7 when I first started teaching turning 15 this year makes me feel old [22:08:59] I still remember them as like tiny [22:09:12] Def [22:09:24] Ive observed some of the junior classes [22:09:33] I can see their fun to work with [22:09:36] I'd never teach in a school though [22:09:46] I don't have the patience for kids who don't want to be there [22:09:53] tf is the difference between foreign exchange and international trade [22:09:57] I had a fairly easy lot to teach [22:10:07] I never really had any big problems [22:10:22] I had a few cheeky ones but they were funny [22:10:43] Never had to tell anyone properly off [22:12:06] I'm off to sleep on that note [22:12:17] Before you make me feel old and bring back memories [22:12:22] Also I got work in the morning [22:15:14] >:) [22:15:29] ill let you know if I finish my masters in citizenship in the world [23:02:18] <.labster> Just for people's awareness, in the great wisdom of the Board we have reshuffled the cabinet and have officers in new positions. Most are unchanged, but @serverlessharej is now President, I am now Treasurer, and @notaracham is taking over as Director of Trust and Safety. https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Board_of_Directors/List [23:03:06] <.labster> We are always looking for people to get more involved, and if you think you can help out the board, or in any volunteer role, do let us know. [23:04:29] mmm. on-wiki T&S rights will need to be transferred at some point [23:04:39] (Official minutes to be posted when approved, but confirming this is accurate as board secretary) [23:04:56] Harej will remain on the T&S team more generally, so no big shifts for now [23:05:41] Will work with the appropriate folks to shuffle rights once things are settled, but thank you for staying on top of it, MacFan! [23:07:17] Huh say wah [23:07:35] so youā€™re still sectrar? [23:07:58] Also chat i made a snow angel i feel so full of joy and whimsy [23:08:13] @notaracham as a heads up, per https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Systems_Access_Policy, you will need to create an official (Miraheze) account as is required for T&S [23:08:31] Board Shuffle: Deals 5 damage and causes Confusion [23:08:57] <.labster> Yeah, most jobs didn't change. We had to shuffle some jobs to allow Harej to be President, like he can't be President/Treasurer for legal/financial reasons. [23:10:27] <.labster> also I believe Harej will stay on within the T&S team, so there's no need to remove rights. [23:10:45] Yep, correct for now. [23:10:56] Probably long-term as well, but the future is the future. [23:11:16] [1/5] Full roster: [23:11:16] [2/5] Chair + Treasurer: Labster [23:11:17] [3/5] President: Harej [23:11:17] [4/5] Secretary + DT&S: NotAracham [23:11:17] [5/5] DTech: CosmicAlpha [23:11:42] (Secretary really isn't a huge time sink outside of board meetings and onboarding paperwork for NDA holders) [23:12:21] Yep, will get to this after dinner, thanks for the reminder.