[00:58:28] I think they look readable; I usually do 100% width [05:57:34] hi [08:18:41] what would cross-platform mean in this instance? [08:22:18] Exactly what it sounds like [08:22:24] It works across platforms [10:48:37] [1/2] in an alternate universe... [10:48:37] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1558431050911186944/image.png?ex=6acb6984&is=6aca1804&hm=dc91bdaf7e7fbab6326e05c66352644eb6fc023007ef3827de98a3fe103d9a67& [10:48:47] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1558431094599319602/image.png?ex=6acb698f&is=6aca180f&hm=0b621c34e6381d9ffcf567187c7a3350d879e4e999174089e2b95deddb8d568b& [11:36:51] 😭❓ [11:39:00] just a glimpse into the good timeline [12:11:15] right now is also a good timeline for wikis [12:11:22] arguably [12:11:43] wikipedia was always independent/unenshittified [12:11:53] and more wikis are increasingly moving away from fandom [12:13:20] but i think wikipedia has notability criteria? [12:13:43] like you can't write some minor characters or separate seasons of less famous works [13:57:25] I'd argue that that is a good thing. [13:58:15] They've got finite resources, notability criteria mean those don't get used up on articles which people won't read. [14:05:00] the notability criteria is why individual wikis exist in the first place [14:05:36] it is possible for a video game character like mario or even for the minecraft creeper to be documented on wikipedia [14:05:58] though these are the exceptions, not the rule. they pass wp's notability guidelines [14:07:22] but something like the dirt block from terraria, the garlic from vampire survivors, scout from deep rock galactic, or any cat from battle cats is not expected to be documented on wikipedia [14:08:28] [their](https://terraria.wiki.gg/wiki/Dirt_Block) [individual](https://vampire.survivors.wiki/w/Garlic) [wikis](https://deeprockgalactic.wiki.gg/wiki/Scout) [will](https://battlecats.miraheze.org/wiki/Tank_Cat_(Normal_Cat)) [14:10:50] wikipedia has pages for I think all of the first 151 pokemon. by modern standards I don't think they'd meet notability criteria [14:23:32] It depends on the pokemon, I think. Pikachu probably would, farfetchd definitely wouldn't. [16:36:55] It’s a mixed thing [16:39:09] It’s absolutely been used by staff with specific biases (not against entertainment but movements and cultural things) but it usually gets worked out, eventually… [16:57:22] [1/4] Resources are not a problem, see [[WP:NOTPAPER]]. The reason why notability exists is essentially because back in the day, people were creating promotional articles all the time, or articles which didn't count as encyclopedic content. Common examples were articles about small companies, individuals' CVs, articles about bands with virtually no following, and articles for [16:57:22] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/WP:NOTPAPER [16:57:23] [2/4] every species of Pokémon. Notability means that now, Wikipedia will reconsider hosting an article about a Serbian village with 1 inhabitant as of 2015 and 0 inhabitants as of 2020. Notability is formalised by the WP:GNG rule, which states that 2 reliable, non-trivial and independent sources must exist for an article to exist. This was a major step towards improving Wik [16:57:23] [3/4] ipedia's content quality, although other processes such as AfC and speedy deletion have helped. Nowadays, notability is primarily enforced for the sake of enforcing notability. This is an easy source of arguments, as is anything involving notability - discussions heat up quickly. [16:57:23] [4/4] I am not sure when all these different facets of projectspace came into being, but my guess is that it was a long time ago, in the early 2000s. [16:57:24] [20:24:25] wikipedia's scope is essentially infinite so it does need some kind of limitation mechanism and I am supportive of that although the application certainly isn't perfect in practice [21:54:53] [1/7] Notability guidelines are potentially Wikipedia's most discussed guidelines (and if you ever spend time on VPP and multiply that by 25 years you'll understand the scale of this claim), with over two decades of proof of work and refinements. It could definitely be done differently, but I wouldn't call it better. Major changes towards relaxing notability, i.e. loosening G [21:54:53] [2/7] NG, certainly wouldn't benefit anyone other than the very rare and rogue topic-specific editor. From my experience, most en-WP editors are generalists, simply because I don't edit about Ancient Egypt so I don't see User:Iry-Hor very often. Some editors bunch up together (WP:VG is a thriving hub, from the perspective of an outsider, of series people) and some don't (WP:W [21:54:54] [3/7] PMH, I am told, is a rather solitary place where everyone does pretty much their own thing). But all in all, if you see a user on en-WP, they are probably a generalist. [21:54:54] [4/7] It is these generalists who shape the policies and guidelines which Wikipedia (in theory and often unsuccessfully) follows. From the perspective of an uninvolved outsider, also known as a reader, they decide what fellow readers would realistically read about and call it encyclopedic content. (almost used MediaWiki markup for italics there, haha!) It is this encycloped [21:54:54] [5/7] ic content which Wikipedia is supposed to (and never will) achieve. That is what Wikipedia's scope is: the scope of an encyclopedia. Which brings me back neatly to the start of your comment. [21:54:55] [6/7] Of course, this is only my interpretation of notability, and everyone has something different to say about it. As I wrote above, it is likely the most discussed part of Wikipedia's processes, though I guess infoboxes and userboxes combined could come close. The most discussion on Wikipedia has got to be all the drama all over the place but especially AN and AN/I. Howeve [21:54:55] [7/7] r, that's unrelated to processes, so I don't count it here. [21:58:02] Sorry about the text wall with a single line break. At least now I know approximately what Discord's message size limit is, lol. [22:26:33] It's a problem that needs to be solved for a universal encyclopedia [22:26:48] And no answer will make everyone happy [22:28:53] Does that time you stubbed a toe count? Probably not. [22:29:48] Does a band in the 90s that played two shows and disbanded count? Debate ensues depending on specifics [23:03:48] realistically what it is and what wikipedia's done with it is not something I can think of any better or realistic approach for, so I take it as the best available deal under the circumstances [23:27:54] What's the problem? [23:51:12] the question of what to include in it, i assume