[00:28:33] @su35.flanker the [00:28:41] Bro [00:28:53] Ur not real [03:52:21] [1/6] There are some copyright concerns with the Industrialist Wiki for Miraheze and Fandom, since we forked from Fandom and changed the license from CC BY-SA (?) Unported to CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, which shouldn't be compatible. [03:52:21] [2/6] When we checked on Fandom, we saw some pages just copy and paste from the Miraheze to the Fandom one, which completely violates the Creative Commons license since no attribution was provided + it was used for commercial purposes. [03:52:22] [3/6] Our options are to file a DMCA, revert those edits ourselves or just leave it as it is. Since we really hate Fandom, we can't just leave it there. But the owner of the game, or the admins of the wiki don't know how to file a DMCA or don't want to file a DMCA, since "the last thing I want is a legal battle", and I doubt they have a registered agent sitting around to provide i [03:52:22] [4/6] ts address rather than theirs. [03:52:22] [5/6] Contributors of the wiki usually aren't eligible to file DMCAs themselves, since they don't "own" the content and instead all the contributors of said page "own" the content. [03:52:22] [6/6] There was also some fidgeting around when attempting to take down Fandom, as they just wanted to flex their "Forking Policy" because, "It's not a move, it's a fork!". Like goddammit, just admit that we want the wiki taken down already! [03:52:28] so uj [03:52:30] uh [03:52:34] help? :? [04:02:31] You can't take existing CC BY SA content and bring that into NC if the right has already been releases [04:02:53] For new content taken back to fandom w/o attribution you can try just talking to fandom staff anyways [04:03:48] If you specifically point out a clear license violation on the grounds of missing attribution (commercial use maybe but less sure) they my be able to lend a hand without a proper DMCA [04:03:54] Couldn't a moved wiki change licenses? [04:04:37] Okay, I'll just find Fandom staff instead. Filing a DMCA seems like a pain in the head anyways. [04:08:09] They can change the licence under which new content is published but existing content can never take back rights that have been given to the public [04:08:59] If someone submits an edit under CC BY SA, they irrevocably grant the right of commercial use as dictated by the license's terms [04:09:16] The editor cannot say 'wait no nevermind i take it back' [04:09:35] They can release more rights (saying their edit is now under public domain) [04:09:48] But that is not something wiki staff can do [04:09:54] [1/3] this is from the wiki themselves i assume all content before 14th March 2025 is CC BY-SA and anything after that is CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 [04:09:54] [2/3] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1568839958876131348/Screenshot_2026-11-08-12-08-39-13_40deb401b9ffe8e1df2f1cc5ba480b12.jpg?ex=6af14791&is=6aeff611&hm=6b72d589c216af5eac1e69df62a8743d1598e455e87f5baf26fa12308263d20f& [04:09:54] [3/3] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1568839959241171035/Screenshot_2026-11-08-12-08-47-03_40deb401b9ffe8e1df2f1cc5ba480b12.jpg?ex=6af14791&is=6aeff611&hm=bd3d1723a657db202b862bdec407938393fa4f50040892ade578984752c10be4& [04:09:58] The copyright of the edit still belongs to the creator [04:10:20] Exactly [04:11:00] so technically when they copied the new content over from Miraheze to Fandom, Fandom violated the license? [04:13:43] If there's no attribution yes [04:13:59] The NC bit is a bit weaker bu [04:14:36] okay thanks [04:14:48] i'll just check edit summary then find Fandom staff right after [04:18:40] https://support.fandom.com [04:39:48] had to use god damn microsoft edge since both zen and ungoogled chromium are too cool for netflix.com, genuinely a nausiating experinece [04:40:00] but it actually lets me watch Death Note so [05:37:24] why we hate fandom so much [05:37:29] other than the ads [05:37:38] https://tenor.com/view/gulp-cat-gif-27257259 [05:37:44] OTHER than the ads [05:39:51] as a miraheze steward and wiki lover who got his wiki start through fandom i personally think a lot of the animosity to fandom is [slightly] overblown, or more accurately misdirected [05:55:31] well. where we direct it properly then [06:01:42] For me, it's complicated [06:02:42] There are numerous controversies, like a Fandom employee plagiarizing from gta.wiki, the grimace incident, how they make forking so difficult [06:02:57] And even I have my own personal issues and history with them too [06:04:31] This is not to say that it's all bad. I think the communities that are still on Fandom (which aren't the Fandom counterparts of forked wikis) are amazing wikis and that a lot of people there are talented editors too [06:05:31] It's where I started and I still have plenty of wikis I'd like to help move over too [06:05:51] [1/2] > the Grimace incident [06:05:51] [2/2] That was the last straw for a majority of wikis. I'll never forgive them for that. [06:08:37] Wasn't the last straw for me [06:09:34] But I did have a mental crashout at one point in like early 2024 [06:11:42] It was rather the accumulation of negativity over time that just made feel like 'why should I really work with Fandom or Fandom Stars if the platform is continuously declining and all that there is is negativity?' [06:13:20] We went from what feels like the Weird Gloop server right now (we're all excited to build the best wikis and talk about best practices and all that) to slowly drifting into endless arguments about forking and the platform's decline [06:17:56] [1/2] My issue is that a lot of people forget that the people who work at Fandom are, well, people, like us. Especially for the community facing staff that have to enforce these predatory policies, a lot of them are genuinely good and nice people who like helping communities and don't like these policies, but they enforce it because this is their job and they need to make a living to sur [06:17:56] [2/2] vive [06:18:12] [1/2] Cook said it pretty well [06:18:12] [2/2] > (for context you have to realize that all the community managers hate this part of the job and fundamentally understand that it isn't fair, and they try to not be the ones to do it) [06:19:00] I keep this nuance very well [06:19:31] And I agree with you [06:20:03] Even a lot of Fandom staff are great people who wanted to help communities and do so for a living [06:20:32] But they didn't really sign up to stop communities from forking, did they? [06:21:27] Most of them were hired before 2022 when forking became more normalized/mainstream and not done as a movement by a handful of communities [06:31:02] this is interesting [09:33:10] [1/2] this is one hell of a wiki request.... [09:33:10] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1568921311663755396/image.png?ex=6af19355&is=6af041d5&hm=e1839f17a2d83f766403b125a746b5005ae4c8eaf5e7780d274ccb431474848c& [12:05:11] <_arawynn> Big nope but not the worst I have seen [12:09:47] I learned today Planking (the trend) is useful exeses [12:42:17] Another thing is a lot of fandom wikis are very very old which means they sometimes have decades of bungled policies. [12:43:43] DC Database and the MegaTen fandom wiki are examples of wikis that just have decades of bad decision making policies that really hurt the site today [12:44:52] There are some independent wikis just as old but they still tend to be a bit better about it in my experiences [12:51:56] [1/2] Yeah. I think a lot of especially younger people have this idyllic world view that people can pick and choose what companies they work for and thus anyone who works for a company like fandom, EA, epic or similar mediocre tech companies are doing so out of moral ambivalence. It’s a cliche, but people have to eat and support their families. [12:51:56] [2/2] Theres probably a line to be drawn. If someone works for Kill Literally Everyone LLC then maybe you can make an argument against them as a person. [12:57:35] netflix requires you to install DRM or something like that [12:58:48] yeah seems like the sort of work where it's not bad enough that you just have to immediately leave and never come back, but not good enough to keep you satisfied [14:56:35] yeah tbh this is why my last straw was when they fired everyone [14:57:25] (I already didn't really like it as a platform before then but that's what made me actively want to leave) [14:58:01] didn't exactly have a 'last straw', but rather slowly phasing out from fandom to indie wiki platforms [14:58:43] Glad I left Fandom back in 2028 [14:59:11] [1/2] on another note [14:59:11] [2/2] https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/615786602454581249/1569003355974537236/image.png?ex=6af1dfbe&is=6af08e3e&hm=dc168324d9f7bf5b050d23985492e3bf188c3aead6ff9fa2346a66ea892e2ee3& [14:59:22] good game with a good indie wiki that never was on fandom [14:59:51] nvm it is a different delta v that I was thinking of [14:59:58] there's this: https://wiki.deltav.gay/view/Main_Page [15:00:04] and then this game: https://delta-v.kodera.pl/index.php/Main_Page [15:00:26] 😆 [15:00:50] 😆 I noticed you noticed my tag [15:00:57] yup [15:01:09] Space Station 14 is good [15:01:12] yeah [15:01:18] space station also has incredible indie wikis [15:01:22] Space Station 13 does not work on WINE [15:10:50] tell them they can selfhost on cloudflare or github pages? [15:11:38] huh [15:11:48] nothing [15:11:51] i don't dare to [15:12:01] enjoy your before -monday [15:12:23] make them host their wiki on wikidot or shoutwiki 🤭 [15:12:42] or fextralife 🤣 [15:12:50] ion get it [15:30:23] Buy cheap VPS. Host wiki on cheap VPS. [15:37:46] I think we should get a time machine and delete drm from ever [15:38:09] In the current day of job markets especially… [15:41:13] If I was out of school and looking for employment in the big 20 something and got no responses back from anyone expect fandom inc, hey honestly at that point not out of the question [15:41:22] Because people need money or else bad [15:41:36] if they were my only option for a job [15:41:40] I'd take it [15:42:09] but honestly, I'm kinda in the middle of thinking of whether a corporate job suits me or not [15:42:25] and stick to freelance/self-employment [15:42:57] Fair nuff [15:43:14] I’m honestly unsure if I would be more opposed to working at fandom or Google [15:43:32] google probably provides more benefits, let's be honest [15:43:54] Based purely on what they do and entirely ignoring the details of getting a job there [15:44:21] On that front no contest absolutely and that definitely skews it lol [15:44:30] Plus the name power [15:44:32] yeah like [15:44:48] You’d be shocked how much you can pull off using the words “I work at Google” [15:44:55] even if it was wiki.gg, i'd think google provides better benefits [15:45:12] though i'd kinda lean more into wiki.gg since it's something i'd enjoy more [15:45:19] idk [15:45:21] ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ [15:45:42] but yeah [15:47:39] wiki.gg is cool but definitely not in a comparable status to fandom as a company, I would guess fandom has them beat on benefits just from being a big corporation with big money [15:48:43] yeah [15:49:05] yeah my exact predicament. I wouldn't consider the likes of BAE Systems or Palantir, but Fandom is all things considered not _that_ bad [15:49:44] https://www.glassdoor.com/Overview/Working-at-Fandom-EI_IE428648.11,17.htm [15:50:06] Fandom may be bad, but mostly particularly so in the periphery of the world of wikis [15:50:08] LMAO oh god no yeah big P is hella pushing it [15:50:24] not like they're downright evil or psychotic like [15:50:35] the two people who own Palantir [15:50:43] sees red dot [15:50:45] "oh shit" [15:50:48] dies [15:51:08] Google, Microsoft, less so Apple, the like certainly aren’t altruistic but still a significant step up than palalalala [16:54:42] If nothing else, working at Google or Microsoft in any noteworthy capacity probably lets you some good resources to do other thngs with. [16:54:59] (source: this xbox documentary I vaguely recall) [17:03:54] True [17:26:14] lmao, /pol/ is to the right sir [17:32:09] yes it does, google widevine or whatever the equivalent was called for Edge [17:32:54] which I kind of want to make a point about since the recent discussion was about you know, is it bad personally to work at a bad company [17:34:18] I think there's a big difference between Fandom and Google [17:36:18] if you're a programmer at Fandom your big crime really is making an impossible to browse wiki because your browser tab keeps crashing on my still supported iPhone with the sheer amount of ads, and now I am annoyed because whatever game info I was looking for is basically impossible to find, which is pretty low on the scale [17:41:37] [1/4] if you're at Google or Apple or Microsoft, you may work on like GMail or Outlook or Office or whatever which are actual productivity tools that make people's life better, but your real job is really serving the same devil OpenAI or Palantir all serve, either in a cynical "well this is just the latest bubble, I'll just get my bag and bolt out the exit before it blows up", or beca [17:41:37] [2/4] use you're like an actual cultist. [17:41:37] [3/4] While RAM Altman and Peter Thiel are way more open about this like we don't care about humanity bit than the more traditional big tech companies, they all ultimately serve the same interests. I don't think there's really any ethical difference between working for like Google and working for Palantir, the former are just less obviously cartoonishly evil about serving the devil, a [17:41:38] [4/4] nd the only ethical move that doesn't involve sacrificing yourself and going to jail is to leave said company [17:42:10] I just don't give a darn [17:44:06] I mean hey, that's most people's opinions right now [17:45:31] but I think you'll see that tech workers will be disliked more and more and even hated for the fact they're tech workers by history, and honestly, can't blame if the future views, well I guess us since I cannot deny I am still a tech worker (although not for long), us that way [17:48:20] I just care about little besides Taerel (wordcounts, writers recruitment/quotas, recruiter quotas and the like) [19:29:51] & [21:17:54] ^ [21:18:27] one day i will be quick switching through #scambot-central and #offtopic and hit K before ctrl and hit enter key and that will be the last of me [21:51:56] you know you can hide the channel right [22:29:34] It's also a soft ban, so you can rejoin a little after. [22:30:01] At least, assuming I've understood it correctly. [22:46:06] This is correct