[01:18:07] Is there a way to make sorting tables better? Since when 1.0.0 is superior to 1.0.2 [01:18:45] its even random sometimes, rn I'm seeing both 1.0.2 anbd 1.0.1 over 1.0.0 [01:22:41] The sorting code in MediaWiki has been a bit wonky. For tables, you might be able to get around it by manually specifying a sort key. https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Help:Sorting#Specifying_a_sort_key [01:23:32] Interesting, thanks for the link, I will have a look at it tomorrow [02:06:28] Hello!! [02:07:19] Welcome, we've unfortunately had lots of drama lately due to the Trust and Safety ban of a former Steward [02:08:48] I'm curious now. [02:08:54] What happened? [02:09:03] That's an interesting way to greet someone [02:10:57] Raidarr, the former Steward I'm referring to, refused to follow several T&S restrictions laid out to him and was consequently T&S banned; many in the community, including myself, saw this as unfair and there was a lot of discussion in this server about the future of Miraheze, coupled with several resignations [02:14:03] He didn't follow only one of those restrictions. [02:14:17] Which is exactly why it was unfair [02:14:31] Yes. [02:14:53] Very unfair. [02:20:21] Is it possible for me to "adopt" a wiki? [02:20:48] You can follow a procedure outlined in [[Local elections]] in order to gain bureaucrat + sysop rights [02:20:48] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Local_elections [02:20:49] [02:21:29] space.miraheze.org is kinda inactive and I wanna do stuff with i [02:37:32] [1/2] Update: if you don't set an alternative image but do select the "force alternative image" anyway, it will not have the big page image. [02:37:33] [2/2] https://thegye.miraheze.org/wiki/Main_Page [02:41:59] Never mind! [02:42:10] I got a friend to give me his wiki [03:01:56] [1/2] hmm maybe a total ban is overboard, however that is cause for instant removal of access from any tools that grants access to PII data. As a formal company, yes that normally would result in dismissal [not eligible for rehire] [03:01:57] [2/2] Owen has to report any violations and explain what steps are taken to prevent repeat [03:02:47] Are image dump requests made through phabricator? [03:04:15] [[SN]] [03:04:15] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/SN [03:04:16] [03:04:50] They were actually banned for something else not even PII issues [03:08:59] Thanks. [03:10:38] also does this mean that Miraheze gonna die soon? >_> [03:11:21] Probably not, but one former user has said that Miraheze only has 6 months left to live [03:12:38] [1/2] That's [03:12:38] [2/2] Not good [03:14:34] [1/3] That's [03:14:35] [2/3] Definitely [03:14:35] [3/3] Not good [03:16:52] and if I said I'm the Queen of England, does that make it true? [03:16:52] [1/3] there's 2 pieces of the puzzle [03:16:52] [2/3] - finances which are good for now [03:16:53] [3/3] - SRE/Infrastructure team which is getting depleted. This is dangerous. [03:17:32] Don't forget the community aspect (e.g. CVT), which is also severely understaffed [03:18:08] community won't matter if you don't have the expertise to keep the servers up [03:21:19] [1/2] the tweet from last night was rather poor and only caused people to start making emergency plans. making emergency plans or preparing for an emergency is fine [03:21:19] [2/2] proper processes and protocols need to be adopted for Miraheze to survive this. know one person who is thinking to jump in if this gets worse... [03:21:46] [1/2] That's the problem here [03:21:47] [2/2] Will there be enough people to run the service itself? [03:22:20] one thing to do immediately is to go review the current team's skills. Don't run software the team is not familiar with. [03:22:57] I don't have a crystal ball, and don't know what Miraheze plans, but the MW upgrade may not happen [03:23:07] Probably not tbh [03:23:15] Yeah, 'cause it's taking forever for 1.40 to come out [03:23:17] well CosmicAlpha is gone [03:23:21] WikiTide will probably upgrade on time though [03:23:40] 1.40 and 1.40.1 probably will have bugs so wait for 1.40.2 [03:23:55] What's wikitide [03:24:14] The free version of WikiForge [03:24:25] That's out already? [03:24:32] Yep, released today. [03:24:57] Huh [03:27:05] There are many stuffs relied on his extensions so even though he moved to WikiForge, he still have to maintain themšŸ¤£ [03:29:05] I am unsure... [03:32:09] Unless there is no one use that on WikiForge, it doesn't look like get abandoned anytime soon [03:32:27] I always handled the upgrades myself when I was in SRE also, then it was going to be Agent I believe who also left, so the 1.40 upgrade on Miraheze has been said by a member of the MediaWiki team to basically be on hold indefinitely as it is difficult for the remaining MediaWiki team to do it themselves... Hey at least 1.39 is LTS. [03:33:21] CosmicAlpha is likely to maintain going forward for wikitide and wikiforge, what happens for miraheze idk [03:36:01] Where is wikitide [03:37:33] meta.wikitide.com [05:54:03] Well, at least it's possible to make a Special:DataDump [07:00:42] I would recommend users have plans for both a controlled and uncontrolled shutdown of Miraheze [07:01:11] Uncontrolled being things die at some point and there's no SRE / SRE for a while [07:01:25] Controlled being you get given a date to leave by [07:02:07] I hope the second is most likely [07:02:23] Could be a combination [07:02:49] with current and upcoming resignations, all teams will be impacted [07:03:17] @agentisa it's impossible to say exactly what will happen [07:03:43] But I think assuming we'll be online for in 6 months time is a not a safe assumption [07:03:46] Today [07:03:54] I agree [07:03:56] It isn't exactly. [07:04:56] better alternatives like WikiTide are thankfully available [07:05:01] Yes [07:05:18] WikiTide / WikiForge would be my recommended option [07:21:30] I guess I'll back up and ask to delete my second wiki, which is failed migration off FANDOM, first [08:05:49] I am not looking forward to yet another migration. [08:08:47] Can someone make a blog post airing all of the current dirty laundry? Because I am totally lost. [08:09:16] tl;dr, new wiki farm same staff mostly as MH, so MH under a different name. [08:10:16] Without repeating the same mistakes and learning from them [08:10:44] ffs guys if y'all's plan was to do that I should have just kept ownership of all of the Miraheze assets /s [08:11:58] and making new mistakes? šŸ™‚ [08:12:25] Everyone makes mistakes, so that is unavoidable probably. There is always room to learn. [08:12:42] I don't mean that in a bad way. I'm basically quoting Larry Wall about Perl 6/Raku. [08:15:16] Ah [08:23:59] Thank you very much information šŸ™‚ [08:28:43] @Stewards Hello stewards, could you please change the https://vikibrawl.miraheze.org/ wiki address to https://heyturkiye.miraheze.org/? I use the wiki as a personal wiki now. (Sorry ping) [08:29:38] This has to be SRE [08:29:39] Stewards don't handle that [08:29:48] Who are unlikely to be doing much for the next few days [08:30:29] fix [08:30:34] @RhinosF1 [08:32:51] i need help on doing infobox and userbox templates on my wiki [08:33:55] Please create a task [08:34:14] Check the pinned messages then create a #support thread [08:34:22] I used to go to Phabricator but now unfortunately I am not available. [08:34:35] sorry RhinosF1 [08:34:42] Discord is not a task tracking system [08:34:49] No phab task = unlikely to be done [08:35:22] Hmm, okey. [08:35:46] I'll go to the Phabricator then. [08:35:58] [[phab:N]] [08:35:58] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/phab:N [08:36:03] [08:37:06] Already did [09:16:31] Ah, I see what happened. All of the most important on-topic information has been hidden in #offtopic . [09:17:49] Yep... [09:32:22] That is the Boards plan, but we're wearing @CosmicAlpha to approve the minutes of the last meeting since Thursday [09:34:46] The major problem is a lot of people creating hysteria not knowing the full information and those that do know it, are adding to it by sharing incorrect information [09:35:13] Further, it's interesting one of those people has created a competitor and is leading the calls to close down Miraheze - to their own benefit. [09:35:49] I will be resigning from the board tonight or tomorrow but I'll approve the minutes. [09:36:06] Especially when they hold a responsibility to ensure the stability of the platform [09:36:52] That might be a good idea as your failing your responsibility as a Director currently, if you have no intention of bringing stability [09:37:18] Goodbye [10:02:48] What do you think if your service is abused to disclose personal privacy? [10:05:58] I will be sharing the minutes shortly - but CA did say a soft approach should be taken against people who misuse personal information [10:12:37] I'm requesting a GDPR so this goodbye from me permanently everyone [10:13:44] Because Owen apparently likes pushing more people out by making things sound or portray them like they aren't. [10:14:45] Because I defended and was against Raidarr's ban before the board, apparently I think there should be a soft approach for PII misuse even though the ban had nothing to do with PII misuse [10:16:01] "TH stated he disagreed with mandatory Data Protection training for all people with access to personal information stating this would make it harder for volunteers to join" there is also this line where you disagree we should train people to effectively handle personal information. [10:16:28] That doesn't even say why [10:17:29] I disagreed because it would be pointless to go through the process of setting all that up if a wind down was done. [10:17:59] You didn't say that and you agreed to that wording [10:20:58] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Board/Policies/20230607-Minutes minutes from the meeting for everyone to review around the whole discussion on Wednesday [10:20:59] And because I didn't know it was required, that part was on me. But the other reason I didn't like it as it would be harder to find volunteers in my opinion in a time when MH was really struggling. If what you said above was true, then why would I have still cared about anything. I sorely misjusged you as someone I formerly trusted Owen. [10:21:37] hey, can we get an #announcements or something for this situation? a lot of users (including myself) are really worried, and some official notice would be nice. even if its "hey, stuff is hitting the fan rn, so prepare for the wrose just in case" [10:21:55] There's more erm pressing matters I believe right now, there's only 1 semi-active Steward atm. Since iirc the other one is on a break at the moment...and with no further viable candidates atm, yikes. [10:22:05] I can try to explain [10:23:32] From what I've seen this whole thing seems to stem from a central thing around Raidarr getting banned from Trust and Safety. Which has erupted into...this over the past few days(?) [10:24:15] I'm an outsider with this though, so that's all I really know up to this point. [10:25:02] regardless, no matter what the cause of it is, having some sort of communication with miraheze's users is important. doesnt have to say why, just mention that something bad is happening and to prepare. worse case, people will be very upset if their wikis suddenly disappear with zero warning... [10:25:22] Yeah I agree [10:25:25] communication should be number one priority [10:25:50] so yeah, if any miraheze admin has the ability to make a ping announcement, please do [10:28:15] https://discord.com/channels/407504499280707585/407504500136607745/1116233264357711952 is still correct at this moment in time šŸ™‚ [10:38:42] should probably be pinged. and from what ive seen in this channel, "not going away for the time being" doesnt seem very certain? but of course, i am not knowledgeable in this scenario. i am simply reading what other users are saying. maybe its just rumors. [10:39:25] my point, is ive seen scenarios like this, where due to similar controversy, everything goes \poof\ with no warning [10:39:41] even if it wasnt planning on going poof [10:40:21] only reason i know this happened is because someone else told me stuff is happening [10:43:28] @Owen requested GDPR please action [10:48:37] The wikis won't go poof without due notice - we would commit to a minimum of a period of a few months where the service would remain up - regardless of events as they occur. Though, we are seeking all avenues to even prevent that being an option on the table. Should that change, ample notice would be given - but at this moment in time, this is not on the table as an outcome. [10:50:27] I'm glad to hear that [10:51:13] I just hope you understand my (and other users') worry, and request for more public communication [10:52:33] No, absolutely I understand it. We wish information came out in a more controlled manner - our intention was to share the minutes of the meeting and then formulate a response, but unfortunately immediately after the meeting ended, it seems information was shared that led to a response while the release of that information was delayed because of following due process. [11:34:36] I have to say, Meta main page is really broken on legacy Vector [12:40:29] @Owen when did <@841439782457704488> resign as director [12:42:54] Around 2 hour ago [12:43:17] Thanks [14:18:05] [1/3] > Rightio, i've been following all the current events (stretching back to a few months ago and thought it best just not to comment but now it's just ridicoulous). And i've been shocked and saddaned by the actions of some of the member of the team. Spreading misinformation, attacking Owen for doing the responsible thing. They've started up a new wiki website and started advertisi [14:18:05] [2/3] ng it and then trying to attack miraheze. I've been a SRE member since 2018 (with one period where i resigned but rejoined shortly after). They got angry because they were being held accountable and then decided to try to burn the place to the ground to setup their own place. This whole criticism of Owen just doesn't work. He's been competent and has worked to try and get more o [14:18:06] [3/3] f the community involved. It's laughable to suggest Owen wants power. He has to do this in his free time and it's not like he's getting paid to run Miraheze. It's not like T&S is some fun thing to do. Also, some of those who have decided to try and blow everything up have shown incompetence and lack of due dilligience. Decided to throw the community under the bus. [14:19:47] are quoting or? [14:20:19] that's my statement [14:23:57] Is this real? [14:24:27] is what real [14:24:30] it's my statement [14:25:02] I mean is this the actual "record" of what inside SRE at that moment? [14:25:04] T&S if it's not a fun place then i wouldn't go there lol [14:25:26] By the way, is this really real? Can you explain the case more deeply? [14:25:27] It's a statement of my own personal view [14:25:39] not a statement of miraheze but a personal statement [14:25:56] oh yea, I mean from your view, not from MH [14:26:33] I suspected there's something like Fandom or something fcked up in SRE [14:27:11] really, really long time ago [14:27:13] I'm sick and tired of seeing the misinformation whilst a few run wild burning everything [14:27:31] Watermelon hmm happy šŸ™‚ [14:27:34] Time someone sticked up to them. [14:28:23] if i don't get my way, i'll burn it down! - the few members of the team [14:29:37] watermelon delight [14:29:43] šŸ˜‹ [14:36:39] [1/2] Also who even propose Global ban Naleksuh? [14:36:40] [2/2] I though we only demote him to normal user [14:37:31] Universal Omega [14:37:37] he offered [14:37:38] dude would remain rude even as normal user [14:37:48] given the history [14:38:02] As Miraheze users, we decided to let Naleksuh go. [14:38:11] Well, I mean demote him to normal user would be enough signal for him to change himself [14:38:44] Global ban is basically no contribution allowed [14:38:52] šŸ’€ [14:38:56] doubtful [14:39:35] If we tell the stewards this can only happen, which is impossible. [14:39:45] ban on official tf2 wiki hasn't changed him, did it? [14:39:54] I'm unfortunately inclined to agree. [14:40:02] [1/2] Agent, since nobody from MH staff has publicly said this "you really need to quit advertising in here and just leave as you so have stated per your resignation". situation does not need to be made worse. [14:40:03] [2/2] yes, I have been blunt for the purpose of pointing out exactly what MH needs to fix. that is way different. [14:40:16] This is no longer possible, the community would have to overturn the global ban [14:40:45] Oh, if he is fully corrupted then Global ban is fair [14:41:13] Prrr skibidi dop dop yes yes-- ohm ohm You are telling the truth [14:41:23] But again that just TF2 Wiki, not the whole MH [14:41:24] I'm still staff \;) [14:41:39] ok and that is conduct unbecoming of staff, no? [14:41:41] Thatā€™s not really an excuse for the blatant advertising youā€™re trying to do. [14:42:02] there's way more than wiki, it's the entire community w/ different assets, he's quite infamous [14:42:17] Bruhhh [14:42:18] Oh, so he is that infamous [14:42:19] -_- [14:42:21] Lol [14:42:24] šŸ’€ [14:42:40] Agent Isai, so why did you leave the server? @agentisai [14:43:32] I'm talking about this server by the way* [14:43:41] Let's leave them be, pleae. [14:43:44] Ah yes, i'll advertise a competor i want to be a part of whilst staying as staff! Lmao. [14:43:47] absolute clown [14:44:18] To resign from admin [14:44:18] Hmm okey prrr skibidi dop dop dop yes yes [14:45:04] Turkiye, please stop spamming [14:45:47] I don't spam so if you say stop bullshit I will [14:46:13] [1/2] I've mostly stayed quiet on the matter up to this point, but do agree with Paladox that former MH volunteers should refrain from speculating on the future of the MH project on this server. [14:46:13] [2/2] Those involved are all adults, we can act in a way that's respectful and reflective of that as things resolve.. [14:46:18] bullshit or spam is same disruptive thing [14:46:37] And yes, Hey Turkiye, please stop scatting in general chat as a response to things I say. šŸ˜„ [14:47:27] Noooo [14:47:37] anyway just kidding [14:47:54] ^ this is type of behavior that earns a server kick at mod discretion [14:47:58] Miraheze may return to its normal severity. <:DoneMH:775407710400675940> [14:48:26] That's accurate, but I'm still having my morning tea. [14:48:51] i'm surprised at the tolerance by mods thus far [14:49:22] https://tenor.com/view/coffee-flapping-butterfly-drink-gif-7843218 [14:49:34] teasrr [14:49:39] šŸ¤£ [14:50:03] Doesn't look like MH is shutdown anytime soon so I will just stick [14:50:15] Anyway, I'll pour tea in the samovar, my dear, he wanted tea. [14:50:33] its not, however the depleting SRE/INFRA teams is concerning [14:50:45] Because they would also kick their former collegue for adversiting, it's actually spam. [14:50:49] not really when you move to LTS [14:51:06] I try to have a cold head and see how things will go [14:51:37] tbh I had more panic back in March [14:51:40] You can return to normal when there are more ppl in SRE [14:52:14] MH is on LTS. the problem is certain software seems unfamiliar to current team hence the concern unless this is inaccurate [14:52:16] šŸ® [14:52:34] Turkey, kind ask to please cut it out, otherwise next step is a time out. [14:53:05] hmm, LTS doesn't get reported in Special:Version? [14:53:09] <:DoneMH:775407710400675940> Ok [14:53:31] 1.39 is LTS last I checke [14:53:58] I wanted to make humor but if that is bad on your part then I won't, well [14:54:06] Indeed LTS but it doesn't enter LTS yet if I'm correct [14:54:07] Wrong venue, wrong time. [14:54:09] Yes [14:54:10] the compulsive urge to respond with random non sequiturs [14:54:12] It's funny those saying the new wiki mostly same mh members but won't repeat the same mistakes are the ones who fucking did those mistakes. The wiki doesn't care about data protection and it has a user who violated the data protection laws. Just incompetent people running to start their own farm. [14:54:34] it doesn't specify if LTS, you can always look up the version [14:54:38] Who violated data protection? [14:55:08] Okey. [14:55:10] _not even going to explain the basics of consequences to data protection violation to those that can't comrprehend it_ [14:57:33] I think Miraheze has a shot at surviving with a proper infrastructure audit. I.e, a lot of wikis could be deleted which could reduce some stain. [14:58:22] not even sure why there are so many personal private wikis just for "testing" [14:58:56] Cuz there is no proper testing ground [14:58:59] a single sandbox wiki should be good enough no? [14:59:22] Luckily I didn't rely on creating another wiki just for sandbox [14:59:25] there's a number of folks that are using MH to then transfer to an offsite wiki [14:59:46] This is a bit of a difficult process, because the global ban after 1 day will be difficult to reopen in the future. If Naleksuh learned from his actions, he can come back, we wait. [14:59:55] A public sandbox exists in PTW, but is also not reset regularly and can sometimes not give accurate results. [15:00:18] Also there's a big reason why ppl use MH for sandbox [15:00:23] My understanding though is that most private wikis are not 'just for testing', though they do have a pretty high dormancy/removal rate. [15:00:26] Like using Cargo or SMW [15:00:40] Tightening wiki creation instead of allowing the free-for-all we currently do would be a good start in order to reduce the number of wikis [15:00:41] looking through wiki discover, I am seeing a couple blatant violations of not copying wmf projects or sub projects [15:00:42] Single edit can broke entire server if not careful [15:01:02] Play to Win?? [15:01:06] Raidarr, owens already said [15:01:23] playground testing wiki? [15:01:30] Please feel free to report them on SN, though it may take a bit for action to be taken given reduced steward capacity [15:01:32] Haa, okey. [15:01:32] PTW = "Public Test Wiki" [15:01:47] AKA: https://publictestwiki.com/ [15:02:59] Owen clarified that Raidarr only violated the IBAN [15:03:39] @notaracham I know you had a worksheet about the abbreviation on Miraheze, do you keep it up? [15:03:41] well, regardless think of the situation as Raidarr got fired as a volunteer [15:04:07] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/User:NotAracham/Miraheze:Acronyms_and_Abbreviations [15:04:15] It will be very helpful for me if you migrate the page to RfC as soon as possible. Because Miraheze has a lot of abbreviations. [15:04:48] would that really honestly require an rfc for a list of literal abbreviations? [15:04:53] what it has to do w/ rfc? [15:04:56] Data Protection was also an aspect of it, that's why restrictions were put in place, amongst other problems [15:05:12] Nice, another one goes to my collection [15:05:22] I believe the intent was to indicate it should move to an official help page vs a user subpage [15:05:25] @Legroom where to talk when a policy is offered [15:05:36] Yes but the ban was because one condition of the restriction was violated [15:05:45] but indeed, restrictions were placed regarding PII [15:05:48] that's not even considered policy, its just information [15:05:56] no diff than faq [15:06:28] Yes, moved [15:06:31] Indeed, because T&S attempted to mitigate the problem to prevent what happened which was a service ban against a high profile contributor when control, mitigation and education was sufficient [15:07:06] PTW added to acronym list [15:07:49] If data protection problems we're never identified, we wouldn't be where we are now as no action would have been taken [15:09:05] you are faster than me NotAracham šŸ˜Ž [15:09:25] I was just going to add the abbreviation. [15:09:51] I just read some of your page. useful page. Must pass into meta namespace [15:10:33] It's been a while since I've been here, what happened while I was gone? [15:10:46] oh hi Blad [15:10:50] hello [15:11:44] [1/2] Start with this accusation: [15:11:44] [2/2] https://discord.com/channels/407504499280707585/407537962553966603/1117095346879868998 [15:12:03] a big ol' drama, in short [15:13:13] thanks [15:14:48] oh, didn't notice the statement [15:14:55] we're still on the same page I'd say [15:14:59] You haven't missed a chapter [15:15:39] @notaracham https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/User:NotAracham/Miraheze:Acronyms_and_Abbreviations#C CD in section C also has another meaning: [[Custom domains]]. [15:15:39] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Custom_domains [15:15:43] [15:15:54] We can add an abbreviation for it. [15:16:30] was it ever used like that? [15:17:00] custom domains aren't brought up that often [15:17:08] in conversations [15:17:11] We can derive a new abbreviation [15:18:00] [1/2] too much abbreviation won't make things better but more confusing [15:18:00] [2/2] abbreviations are good for things which are used/said very often [15:18:13] [1/2] ??? [15:18:13] [2/2] What is meaning of this yellow part? [15:18:14] and are too long [15:18:35] We can do it to tell new users or to link their wiki to a private domain. [15:18:58] formally saying you shouldn't do that again [15:19:10] I don't see the logic in this [15:19:11] I can't say anything about the change that has been rolled back 2 times, whatever you say is for me too. [15:19:17] for your information [15:19:41] I just wanted to help the stewards with the vote count. [15:19:59] No one is talking about edit content. [15:20:38] The reason I said don't get involved; You are not a steward. [15:20:48] OMG [15:20:51] You are? [15:20:52] That's why I said, don't take it personally. [15:20:58] what [15:21:25] Okay, we can close the case. There is no need to discuss something that has been taken twice [15:22:07] Abbreviations should only be added if they are regularly used in conversation [15:22:17] I've never heard custom domains used as the CD abbreviation as you discuss [15:22:44] If it's not common parlance, it's just confusing. šŸ™‚ [15:22:55] šŸ‘ [15:24:13] Good morning (almost good afternoon) folks, how are we doing? [15:24:26] hi [15:24:50] we're fine, we continue in normal Miraheze chat šŸ™‚ [15:24:57] How are you? [15:25:47] Been extremely busy IRL, but been reading the chat logs off an on and it seems like there's still some concern for the future of the platform [15:26:34] what's bad? is it relevant here? @AmandaCath [15:27:30] well, there are some arguments still, but it's hard to determine platform's fate anyway [15:27:34] at this moment [15:27:53] Note: By the way, worry is a bad thing for me, don't get me wrong. [15:29:06] The [[Fundraiser]]s made to Miraheze every year or the [[Donate]] made daily are the things that keep Miraheze alive. [15:29:06] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Fundraiser https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Donate [15:29:10] [1/2] [15:29:10] [2/2] [15:29:26] As I've mentioned previously, I want to help preserve the service in whatever way I can... but my SRE application is now stalled on Reception being away, and I don't technically qualify for any of the global community roles [15:29:33] When these are finished (that is, when they come to an end), the fate of the platform becomes clear. [15:30:42] Unfortunately my personal finches are quite tight, so I don't think I can make the monetary contribution easily. That's why I'm seeking to volunteer time and skills wherever possible [15:30:43] SRE and T&S are not good jobs in my opinion. [15:31:01] However, I wish you the best of luck with your SRE application. [15:31:01] Personal finances* [15:31:08] Finance wise, Miraheze is good for at least 9 months right now [15:31:13] Yeah, in any event, Miraheze won't blow up overnight [15:31:19] This year's Fundraiser went well [15:31:33] @Hey TĆ¼rkiye while having money helps, the farm would have a hard time surviving due to the lack of volunteers namely on SRE [15:31:47] T&S I'd agree is not a great job, I would think that global sysop and steward, and SRE, would be better [15:32:13] [1/2] To reiterate Void's annnouncement for those on the IRC side of things: [15:32:14] [2/2] ```Hi all, a few volunteers have decided to part with the project as a result of a recent decision by Trust and Safety. There's been quite a few negative things said about the project's future, so I just wanted to leave a note here saying that Miraheze isn't going anywhere for the time being. We will keep you updated on what changes.``` [15:32:30] As of the moment, that still applies. [15:32:38] SRE is one of the important stones for Miraheze, but it is not what we can do at SRE. [15:32:52] otherwise everyone will volunteer for SRE [15:33:25] *Still applies as the most current status of things [15:35:06] God knows what's going on at T&S. If T&S doesn't force us, I'm ready to volunteer. [15:35:20] Any chance that MacFan4000 or Void could process my application? Or is it something only Reception can do? [15:35:58] T&S definitely needs more than one active person if it is to continue to exist as a separate group [15:36:12] Not sure that I could do that job though [15:36:31] I'm not qualified - I wouldn't even have access to on-board [15:37:00] current policy would require that Reception123 review it as the SRE manager [15:37:16] Not everyone is sure. [15:37:21] What do you mean? [15:37:49] I said we don't know what's going on at T&S. [15:38:01] Not a lot is going on currently [15:38:16] MacFan is just an MWE so he can't approve. Void technically isn't EM though de facto he sort of is so yes, only Reception can approve and then forward to Void for final approval as the de facto EM for Infra [15:38:56] Officially Reception is the Interim EM Infra [15:39:11] Looks like there was an emergency board meeting... for future reference are those live-logged in -meetings? [15:39:30] Those don't take place in public discord/IRC channels [15:40:02] So board meetings aren't open to non-members? Interesting [15:40:42] Most corperations/organizations I know of will have public-facing board meetings at least occasionally [15:40:55] Normal board meetings are also held confidentially to everyone. [15:41:12] The agenda and minutes are made public after the fact, see https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Board/Policies if you're curious [15:41:29] I saw that... that's why I was asking [15:41:41] if there was any way to attend the meeting live [15:42:03] [[SRE]] [[T&S]] [15:42:03] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/SRE https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/T%26S [15:42:04] [1/2] [15:42:04] [2/2] [15:43:52] Interesting that T&S doesn't even have any information on how to apply [15:43:58] Agenda is usually made live a week before the meeting, meetings currently are always held in private but if nothing private was being discussed, there's no reason why in the future occasionally a meeting could be held in a public venue [15:44:37] Not going to get any new volunteers for roles that don't tell you how to get involved, or what qualifications are required [15:45:30] šŸ—‘ @notaracham [15:45:40] T&S isn't a constantly open position, it's opened by the Board and closed by the Board. Last time recruitment was open was July last year [15:46:33] But when 50% of the board is also 100% of T&S, I feel like that creates a sticky situation [15:46:42] any plans for emerge board elections? [15:46:44] I looked at the T&S page but there is only @Owen šŸ˜¦ [15:46:54] Exactly ^ [15:46:56] If the board meeting was open to everyone it wouldnā€™t be a board meetin [15:47:45] Most organizations I've worked with will have a board of directors/trustees meeting that is open to public attendance [15:48:02] Can we start hiring again in July? [15:48:07] if anything private needs to be discussed they will break out into executive session temporarily [15:48:09] depend of what kind of board [15:48:13] It's almost July. [15:48:48] It doesn't have to be in a July, it's just when the Board agrees to open such a process, which will be at the next meeting in July likely [15:49:13] I like kind of board that is private and if there is no private info then it can be released to public for view [15:49:36] ah, i'm bored [15:49:37] Board elections for the community are free to be opened at any time - same for technical director given that is now vacant [15:49:38] A few orgs will actually hold their meetings as a town hall of sorts where members of the public can register to speak or pre submit statements [15:49:50] anyway i'm sleepy good night [15:49:56] šŸ„±šŸ„° [15:50:06] [1/2] Please do consider making an announcement pointing to the latest meeting and with whatever other info you could share when possible, all this doomsday talk is making too many people nervous. Also, the control of Twitter account being in SRE's hands is problematic if members post messages that make it appear like the platform is about to go belly up the next [15:50:06] [2/2] instant. [15:51:11] The latter point about social media is indeed valid and will be reviewed. The Board never took control of them as SRE asked to keep it. [15:51:27] Agendas are also posted on discord and meta when released usually [15:51:29] ya could make ur own self hosted wiki to practice ur SRE Skills AmandaCath [15:51:37] I feel like social media should remain an SRE thing. It's not a good idea to create too many subgroups/subcommittees especially when the total roster is stretched thin [15:52:31] That's one oft he issues with T&S... it's dividing the work up too many ways with not enough people [15:52:33] I might not have made myself clear enough. I was asking for a visible announcement (a blog post maybe?), not something buried in RecentChanges on Meta [15:53:14] Cocopuff2018 I don't have the time or the money to run my own wiki... that's why I'm here [15:53:17] Point taken, will consider that next time šŸ™‚ [15:53:57] AmandaCath: They should retain control to able to post messages related to server maintanence and the like but I cannot think of anything else they might need access for. [15:54:13] T&S has historically had no work besides GDPR requests which were handled with 2 people with good coverage. Even now, those requests are being handled in under 24 hours [15:54:38] Void is also able to handle such requests, so the Board maintain the appropriate abilities as well [15:54:39] there are stuffs that require specialized hardware, even a "strong" PC can run very slow for some reason [15:54:57] whats the future plans for miraheze as of now Owen [15:55:02] So wait.. all T&S bans are for GDPR violations of some sort [15:55:30] No, GDPR requests are different to T&S bans [15:55:55] what is miraheze's plan for its lost of volunteers? [15:56:16] But is that what the "RemovePII log" that I sometimes see in RC is? Users who need to have their data purged for some reason for another? [15:56:19] Likely running LTS version of Mediawiki while looking for new solutions [15:56:21] beautiful purple color [15:56:37] we not gonna flood miraheze with LTS [15:56:39] Technically nothing happened for normal users or editors [15:57:03] https://meta.miraheze.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=removepii - is a log of all GDPR requests done [15:57:13] About 200 in the last year [15:57:18] Remember the next major MW update is extremely hard to pass [15:57:59] https://phabricator.miraheze.org/T10915 [15:58:00] As someone who isn't super familiar with GDPR.. what exactly gets removed, and who is eligible to request it? [15:58:43] all PII, the owner (or under behalf) can request GDPR removal [15:58:58] It's an irreversible vanish of your account on Miraheze, all PII and everything removed [15:59:37] So even a username is considered PII even if it's not your real name [16:00:26] It is, yes [16:00:28] under GDPR [16:00:40] Yep, technically you can combine with other info to make yourself identifiable [16:00:47] Hmm.. interesting [16:01:00] Social media should be the pr team not sre unless sre is giving technical updates which should still be duty of pr team [16:01:04] anything that results PII are eligable for GDPR removal [16:01:07] Even though GDPR only applies to EU citizens, T&S usually allows non-EU citizens to claim it and vanish themselves [16:01:08] I am not weighing in on this *at all*, but the following is relevant: [16:01:24] we don't have a PR team? [16:01:52] PR was sort of the responsibility of CES [16:01:53] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/personal-information-what-is-it/ / https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/individual-rights/ / https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/childrens-information/ [16:01:59] Agent was essentially this prior to their resignation as the Community Engagement Specialist [16:02:09] Ah, Agent beat me to it. šŸ™‚ [16:02:16] I would've never thought that a pseudonymous username would qualify as PII [16:02:27] even password does [16:02:51] actually I believe Agent still has SRE permissions [16:02:56] well, yeah, that's obvious. Not so much PII but security [16:03:02] Iā€™ve also been doing a lot of the social media posts [16:03:11] They do, I was referring to their resignation of other roles [16:03:11] A password is actually not technically PII [16:03:19] Pr or community coordinator [16:03:26] As a password can't identify a specific living individual [16:03:40] technically it's SRE Community Engagement Specialist [16:03:43] I mean in case of password are raw text and somehow identify someone, that would be valid for GDPR [16:03:52] I wouldn't think that a bad actor could figure out someone's identity with just a pseudonymous user name and nothing else [16:03:58] All passwords are hashed [16:04:23] Hmmm, I thought he was retiring the CES SRE and retaining the MW SRE, but šŸ¤· . Either way, errands to run, later all. [16:05:05] [1/2] do you know hashed password are crackable with bruteforce? [16:05:05] [2/2] Unless it was totally RNG, I believe it was PII [16:05:10] tech team shouldn't be issuing on social media period. They can inform the community coordinator to post relevant [16:05:18] technically, I was CES with mw-admins access [16:05:23] so I wasn't an MWE [16:05:38] suprised ur still here agent' [16:05:40] WMF recently introduced a new stronger hash algorithm [16:05:40] We don't have one. Even the SRE CES is connected to SRE. [16:06:09] let me ask this ya know when you do edit logged out ur ip shows in the log [16:06:17] Sounds like a role needs filling [16:06:28] it isn't vacant, yetā„¢ļø [16:06:50] It blatantly is. [16:06:54] Seriously, resign already and walk away [16:07:06] And hand over control [16:07:16] Let's not force people to do things they don't want to [16:07:29] He already signaled he quit [16:07:40] I need a cuppa [16:07:48] still agent said he was leaving but still here [16:07:49] Our resources are stretched thin enough as is, if one of the "resignations" has second thoughts that's actually a good thing [16:07:54] people change there mind ya know [16:07:58] It's not like I'm hogging something others can't do right now [16:08:08] Yes letā€™s play be respectful and donā€™t hurry users into doing things that they donā€™t want to fully do yet [16:08:11] SRE has social media and on-wiki access right now [16:08:14] please* [16:08:22] Amanda, the issue is agent is blatantly advertising a competitor [16:08:51] @m3w that doesnā€™t mean that a resignation should be hurried [16:08:55] Where? [16:08:59] Yes, two mentions is enough to oust me [16:09:07] Scroll to last night [16:09:19] I'd qualify blatant as an @ everyone or private canvass [16:09:58] Wait, the discussion of the new premium thing? [16:10:08] That's not "advertising a competitor" [16:10:13] The free version of the premium thing dropped [16:10:17] and I mentioned it twice [16:10:31] Isn't that run by Universal Omega? [16:10:38] Currently, it is [16:10:38] not a "competitor" [16:10:42] This isn't even normal circumstances for a transition, agent and CA unfortunately have blatantly violated social norms [16:10:43] It's not two mentions but that's not the point. You remain a volunteer for MH so we as the community just expect better from you [16:10:56] Agent is a staff member [16:11:28] Agent left server to get rid of staff role [16:11:35] Server staff role, yeah [16:12:04] This is blatant clown behaviour. Either youā€™re in or youā€™re out Agent, you canā€™t be both. [16:12:07] I mean, it is a competitor as it was setup to compete against Miraheze and has also imported a bunch of pages that still reference Miraheze and it's policies and processes [16:12:20] [1/2] AmandaCath - 07:04 today: [16:12:20] [2/2] https://wm-bot.wmcloud.org/browser/index.php?start=06%2F10%2F2023&end=06%2F10%2F2023&display=%23miraheze [16:12:22] Mentioning/discussing a project that's run by a colleague (ex-colleague?) that has been discussed extensively on-wiki isn't inappropriate at all [16:12:22] Agent if you intend to help then don't undermine. You can respectfully point out serious issues [16:12:44] I won't undermine, not at all, the initial ire is gone [16:12:53] why undermine a project I dedicated so much to? [16:13:07] thought it was supposed to be a premium "expansion" of Miraheze [16:13:10] This wasn't discussed on wiki - in fact in discussions on wiki it was said there wouldn't be a free version and then it dropped all of a sudden a free version [16:13:13] It's not just Discord, the advertising has extended to Meta as well. [16:13:44] CA resigned and walked away, well should be walking away in full [16:13:52] luckily it doesn't but the bad thing as I said way before which I linked to paladox [16:14:23] Miraheze is slow right now [16:15:35] One of the major problems raised on wiki by the community is this new venture would take all the volunteers who actively contributed to Miraheze - funnily enough, quite a few have gone over and created accounts more or less immediately and some have been given rights such as Steward [16:15:53] Directly in contradiction to what was promised on wiki and to the community [16:15:54] The premium expansion concept was contingent on reaching a deal to bring WF (which was a separate service before the RfC) under the MH banner. This wasn't successful, as is evident by these discussion. [16:16:14] Discussions actually never started [16:16:22] So it's effectively a fork of MH [16:16:29] @Owen seriously just remove the folks whom have effectively resigned in full without giving proper notice for transition purposes [16:16:30] nothing necessarily wrong with that [16:16:42] Was referring to this general chat, rather than the merger discussions, but yeah, that's also what I gathered [16:17:13] @Stewards @Site Reliability Engineers When we're done discussing WikiTide, someone didn't get rights on their wiki (https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Special:RequestWikiQueue/32889) [16:17:27] Are you out of your mind? [16:17:30] @Orduin: ^ [16:17:41] Mods, please delete that [16:17:46] This was about a miraheze wiki, not wikitide [16:17:50] Forking the project is actually one of th most common outcomes of "constitutional crises", both real or perceived [16:17:54] M3w, gonna have to ask you to chill out or get a timeout [16:18:18] There is indeed nothing wrong with a fork of Miraheze, but let's not utilise positions on Miraheze to promote competitors [16:20:39] IIRC, a couple years ago when the WMF T&S-banned an EN Wikipedia admin for alleged disputes with another user off-wiki, there was a community uproar with serious talks of forking, coupled with mass resignations [16:21:10] The fork never actually happened, and most of the resignations ultimately returned [16:21:25] So let's not get too far ahead of ourselves here [16:21:32] looks at ZH Wikipedia and Qiuwen Wiki which actually started [16:21:53] I recall with Freenode the manangement takeover caused mass resignations and the startup of Libera by the former staff, and the remaining staff strongly disagreeing with what the former staff were saying [16:22:03] Scare tatics from "competitors" [16:22:15] (note: Qiuwen is a ZH Wikipedia fork after the 2021 WMF Office Action that is highly censored to PRC's views) [16:22:20] I would also like to note, the Board has made an offer for Raidarr to return if they complete relevant training we initially offered them. So this isn't a final you'll never return decision - it's appealable and it can be moved forward from. [16:22:23] so forks aren't "not a thing" [16:22:28] but they aren't an issue either [16:22:42] I know I'm very new here and entirely unaware of these "competitors" and whatnot, but this just comes across like more potential drama [16:22:54] Why can't we be friends šŸŽµ [16:23:17] [1/2] The level of pettiness in people that should be showing a higher level of professionalism given their roles, even if unpaid, is astonishing, it would be hilariously comical if it wasn't affecting some core mechanisms. I guess every online, volunteer project tend to experience this kind of dramas and setbacks sooner or later but it's always sad to see one going on live, public soc [16:23:18] [2/2] ial media. You people should take a bit more conscioussness about what your roles imply in terms of project's reputation (if you really care about it, that's it). After some time we all tend to forget what are we actually representing due to our personal, constant interactions, but as an outsider this is getting ugly to see. Cool heads make a long way [16:23:23] Uhhhh, freenode was taken over by some extreamist [16:23:25] that's good to hear, but if the issue was mismanagement of PII wouldn't simply revoking their access to PII have been a better remedy [16:23:34] Owen ^ [16:24:01] trump supporter + free speech absolutes - so hate speech etc was allowed [16:24:04] This place is still recovering from the drama with Dicknuts (that's my lovey dovey nickname for Nale), last thing we need is drama between staff [16:24:08] Is that what "OB accepted the idea of making the service ban conditional on the completion of data protection training, and requested this be only on appeal from the subject following remorse also being shown for the impacts the actions had on people." was referring to? Raidarr actually contacted T&S or Board? If so, which one? [16:24:38] Itā€™s not that simple, Amanda. Data Protection is a serious issue. [16:24:49] ^Especially in EU [16:25:01] ^Especially in EU [16:25:02] I saw that [16:25:22] We can be friends in the EU [16:25:48] Sadly I don't have money for travel [16:25:53] PII was managed by a restriction, and another restriction was placed to prevent further law breaking. Training was offered, it was refused and other restrictions broken. Removal of access was fully on the plan if refused, but a clear consequence had to come of escalating behaviour that was becoming more and more serious around harassment and stalking [16:26:10] this [16:26:23] Hi! [16:26:33] this tbh. This is what shocked me. [16:26:33] So will we be getting that review I asked for? [16:26:52] So if data protection is that serious, why does CheckUser even exist on Miraheze? Shouldn't PII be restricted to the highest levels of SRE to access server-side only? [16:26:58] Raidarr didn't contact us, this was out forward by Void as a remedy to be offered [16:27:10] also i agree with the board taking over communcation platforms. [16:27:44] The Trust and Safety actions were reviewed in full by the Board [16:27:56] Oh well, that means he is not returning. Too many people have already started working on WikiTude Meta. [16:28:17] Someone didnt review the request in full then, I specifically dictated trust and safety and board actions. [16:28:24] Because CheckUser is a tool that people are trusted to use and not to violate data protection guidelines. [16:28:33] There have been no Board actions to my knowledge? [16:28:38] Yeah checkuser basically shows people's IPs [16:28:50] Since the beginning of incorporation? I seriously doubt that [16:29:13] Everything the Board has done has been noted in minutes [16:29:21] Yeah Iā€™m aware [16:29:38] what is the topic? [16:30:03] Okay, why does the Miraheze NDA need a physical ADDRESS [16:30:10] [1/2] There was a time on Wikipedia in the 2000s when I was being e-stalked by some harasser who followed me onto Wikipedia. I had the bright idea of posting a fake suicide note on my userpage to throw the stalker off. Couple days later I had the local police show up at my house for a safety check. Turns out the cops can track you down easily with just an IP address, and it turn [16:30:10] [2/2] ed out that other editors on Wikipedia contacted staff who contacted Law enforcement [16:30:16] Yes, Amanda. [16:30:24] Even the WMF doesn't require that [16:30:24] NDAs require your address. [16:30:27] But checkuser can easily be abused just because there is a log private information can always still be linked [16:30:43] Yes they do for a true nda [16:30:51] It was likely the Checkuser-allowed people back then who got my info for law enforcement [16:31:04] I would be surprised if the MH one doesnā€™t require an address. [16:31:58] Last I checked anyone can sing the WMF confidentiality agreement with just your SUL username on Phabricator Legalpad [16:32:03] sign*& [16:32:11] Thats not an NDA [16:32:15] A confidentiality agreement is not an NDA [16:32:16] AmaaaaaandaaaaaaaCaaaaaaaaaath šŸŽµ [16:32:18] thats a confidentially agreement [16:32:24] K make me a checkuser, I sang a name [16:32:33] To sign a WMF NDA you have to have a c-level employee sign off and work with wmf legal [16:32:35] No Spam please [16:32:37] You don't just get checkuser fool [16:32:44] Sorry :< [16:32:47] and yet that's sufficient for CheckUser and Oversight accces [16:32:53] Its not [16:33:02] Oversight isn't as sensitive tho as checkuser [16:33:21] They have to give wmf their physical address and work with WMF to sign a many page document on a legal document platform [16:33:36] Ive done the process before [16:33:40] Real ID of any kind is most certainly not required for non-WMF employees who are CU/OS/Arb/Steward [16:33:44] No problem šŸ™‚ [16:33:50] Yes it is amanda [16:34:00] When you sign a NDA at WMF do you have to give a photo ID too [16:34:03] The important thing is not to make a mistake, but not to make the mistake again. [16:34:06] Problem is some folks just don't care about the legal aspects and use Checkuser for negative stuff. Like good ol' Michaeldsuarez on Wikipedia in the 2000s who used it to find personal info of people he had disagreements with as a sysop, to make articles on them on EncyclopediaDramatica [16:34:08] I know it was historically, but it's not anymore [16:34:19] It still is amanda [16:34:29] Ive literally done the process before [16:34:42] It's been mentioned by enwiki ArbCom before that real ID isn't required anymore [16:35:03] As of what date [16:35:12] And when did zppix last do it [16:35:13] Iā€™m not arguing with you, WMF has several different legal documents depending on level of access [16:35:25] I promise you they still get physical address for cu/os access [16:35:29] Oh nevermind, different levels [16:35:58] I'm out of my element here so I'm just gonna šŸ¤ [16:36:39] You can ask any steward they would tell you that they had to get with legal to sign a NDA [16:36:43] I also agree that the CheckUser tool is being abused, it's clearly done illegally. I was blocked on trwiki because of someone else's puppet just because of this, and on top of that I got a global ban on WMF for being his puppet. [16:37:16] It is obvious that CheckUsers are not doing their job properly. [16:37:52] aka right tool used by wrong person [16:38:21] I can't even contact CheckUser which gave me the block, it changes every 6 months. no reply to emails [16:38:43] I retired from WMF not expecting the stewards to take care of me either. [16:39:03] [1/2] Well in michaeldsuarez's case, his being a sysop of Encyclopedia Dramatica and doxxing people caught up to him in the mid 2000s and he was de-sysopped and banned on wikipedia, and de-sysopped from the dozen other 3rd party wikis he was adminning on at the time. He was one of the more prolific editors out there and held admin on many wikis while harassing people. He's now c [16:39:03] [2/2] onsidered a "lolcow" by the very people he used to be looked up to by [16:39:33] And as a former victim of his, I couldn't be happier [16:40:00] <:EpicFaceMH:912930767972225095> [16:40:03] I think people actually contacted his parents at one point, given he used his real name and told everyone he was from new york [16:40:16] šŸ’€ [16:40:38] I don't plan to join WMF again. They unjustly blocked me [16:40:40] at least as of 2021 it was confirmed that WMF no longer required real ID for CheckUser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Arbitration_Committee/Noticeboard/Archive_47#Changes_to_functionary_team_2 [16:40:59] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2012-07-23/Arbitration_report [16:41:08] That's a good read on michael [16:41:52] And in that discussion, it was noted that real ID hadn't been required "for years" so likely it was dropped long before tat [16:42:25] @notaracham [16:42:49] damn .... [16:43:00] Shall we translate your abbreviation worksheet as a help page? [16:43:25] I think this page is important for Miraheze. [16:45:35] Correction: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/F%C3%A6 is the good read, including a comment from Michael himself where he admits to making articles on people. This case led to his downfall on most wikis. [16:45:52] Zppix ^ [16:47:50] The practices on WMF don't matter much here anyway. If anything, this shows we take an extra precaution that they don't [16:48:19] If I was you, that would be in my plan [16:48:38] Why does it matter where someone lives anyway? [16:48:51] I don't see the connection between that and being trusted to handle PII [16:48:55] [1/2] stalkers [16:48:56] [2/2] shitty countries [16:49:03] [1/2] selfharm, etc... [16:49:03] [2/2] Virtual internet, real damage [16:49:24] Stuff going on offline like scheduled power outages? [16:49:45] Likely, especially with physical hardware [16:49:50] But what does any of that have to do with being trusted to handle a limited amount of (semi)-private information? [16:50:46] [1/2] When i was appointed to WMF OC on February 2021, i was not required to provide ID. [16:50:46] [2/2] When i signed NDA around 2019, i was not required too (but it may be different) [16:51:28] It's definitely not gotten any stricter... as I noted it hasn't been required since at least "years" before 2021 [16:52:03] and I'm pretty sure that confidentiality agreement is effectively the WMF's NDA for non-employees [16:52:29] Internet is such a dangerous place, even there's nothing suspicious but can make someone doing weird things [16:53:06] Like, stewards will assign CU/OS after an ArbCom appointment or community vote as long as the SUL username has signed the Phab Legalpad document and they are listed on a noticeboard on Meta [16:55:29] so just looked to confirm, and yeah, it appears that unless you actually work for the Foundation, the only thing you need to do is sign this https://foundation.wikimedia.org/wiki/Legal:Confidentiality_agreement_for_nonpublic_information [16:58:36] Though this has no bearing on Miraheze - we have an NDA in place which is required for these rights. This is the risk that the company has chosen to take, given it's small size, small legal footprint and small operating capital [16:59:22] A physical address is by far much more PII than an IP address and a user agent... so effectively MH requires you to divulge twice as much PII than you'll get access to in return. That may be affecting the number of volunteers for the relevant roles [17:00:27] I was considering running for Steward especially if Reception ultimately resigns, but I don't think I will because of that [17:00:32] AmandaCath Yes, only this one. [17:00:40] But that's one person's information as opposed to a few thousand people's information [17:01:19] Also how would we in theory launch legal proceedings against something with just their IP which could be a VPN and an online pseudonym? [17:01:34] Ask WMF that. [17:01:38] It represents high risk for low reward [17:01:45] if Reception resigns, Miraheze will be down to 2 CVT, 3 SRE, and 1 steward [17:01:57] and SRE has no EMs [17:02:14] Sure, I'll ask their team of several lawyers if I can do what they do with no resources, no qualification and no experience [17:02:26] And no capital either to back it up with [17:02:47] Well, you would need a lawyer to initiate legal proceedings anyway [17:03:23] Which we would seek relevant legal advice for - doesn't mean we need to hire one 24/7 to be specialist in this for us [17:03:58] Alternatively with an NDA as written, we can launch relevant proceedings as needed without going through hoops to locate an individual if that is ever so required [17:04:23] It significantly reduces the risk to us as a company and allows us to offer the same little reward back to the community [17:04:40] Otherwise, we may have to consider when and how we give out such access [17:06:01] Guess UK doesn't have the equivalent of Section 230 that protects most nonprofits like WMF from legal action in all but the most severe circumstances [17:06:51] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Community_noticeboard#IRC_Group_Contacts:_Part_2 @Tali64 I would be grateful if you could inform me about this issue. [17:06:57] Barring copyright infringement and stuff like that, the WMF is protected from most other legal stuff, I think [17:07:21] We are a private limited company unfortunately so have no such protections [17:08:47] Raidarr was put under several T&S restrictions, one which he refused to follow and was subsequently T&S banned for; afterward, following community backlash, the Board held an emergency meeting and came up with a plan to allow Raidarr back onto Miraheze provided that he complete data protection training [17:10:42] So, did OrangeStar say who wants to be GC should press the add topic button or did I misunderstand? [17:10:54] Yes [17:11:15] So what is GC? [17:11:24] Group Contact [17:11:54] They are the ones who interact with Libera (IRC) network staff on behalf of Miraheze [17:11:57] Hmm, okey. Thank you information [17:12:20] I'm not eligible to be a GC right now. [17:12:46] Well, there aren't any official requirements [17:13:07] At least none have ever really been established [17:14:05] By the way, it was seriously frustrating when Raidarr got in and out of the butler [17:14:53] I didn't know there was a butler involved [17:14:58] stewardship is a really important role, it's really ridiculous to go in and out [17:14:59] But maybe he was the one who did it [17:15:40] servant? [17:15:45] It's also next-to-impossible to get stewardship, between the social requirements and the NDA [17:15:47] i'm so congused [17:16:17] From where? [17:16:27] butler? [17:16:29] servant? [17:16:39] Yes [17:16:52] I...what [17:17:37] here butler is used instead of bro in Trabzon. [17:17:45] that's why i'm asking [17:17:50] The reason Stewardship is so hard is the community requirements - but that's expected of a developed community to trust those who they place in such positions [17:18:19] The NDA has never been identified as a blocker to anyone - in fact a few have signed it who have actually never needed it or used it in any way [17:20:12] I believe the confidentiality agreement is something serious. [17:21:26] The fact that Raidarr resigned like this and became a back-stealer has completely destroyed my trust in him. [17:21:55] NDAs don't really stop leaks either [17:22:18] That recent TF2 dev repo gigaleak in January 2023 was of content that you had to pay $2,500 and sign an NDA to access [17:22:22] Untrained personel are more likely to leak stuffs [17:22:39] People just modified the created/modified dates of the files before leaking them to make it harder for Valve to track down the leakers [17:22:54] It honestly all sounds like a moderation issue [17:23:06] Precisely [17:23:34] Staff just publicly having a meltdown and quitting is a big issue [17:23:38] To Miraheze, I've never seen anyone take NDA seriously. [17:23:56] everyone is trying to find each other's vulnerability [17:24:03] Hold your horsesā€¦ hold on, lets get some facts straight here, nothing was leaked, nothing. Letā€™s also make something else clear, Raidarr willingly resigned from steward, his T&S ban came after he had requested her account be vanished per GDPR [17:24:16] This is how it is in real life. no one has any privacy anymore. [17:24:39] And you know, from of expression and stuff, but goddamn waking up to a part of staff just walking out the door after getting told the truth but a rando was hilatiously scary [17:24:56] what does this even mean? [17:25:10] We live in a society [17:25:22] These days internet tracks you before you know about it [17:25:30] I'm telling you how many times he resigned from the stewardship and came back. [17:25:41] Butler is not a toy [17:25:42] I want to help the project in any way that I can. But with my SRE application blocked by Reception's absence, and steward requiring an NDA that I'm not sure I'm comfortable signing... does anyone have any suggestions? [17:25:54] Even worse, only like 0.1% ppl on earth actually care about "privacy" [17:26:03] SRE also requires NDA last I checked... [17:26:11] ^ [17:26:14] only for shell access? [17:26:15] it indeed does [17:26:21] does software engineer actually have shell access [17:26:44] Anything with server access needs an NDA [17:26:46] I'm not aware of any exemptions to the requirement of NDA [17:26:53] the first time he resigned was due to personal problems [17:27:04] As Software Engineer, you'll have free rein to our extensions and such which can be a risk [17:27:10] the second time was due to his T/S restrictions [17:27:11] I suggest you; I think don't apply for SRE at all @AmandaCath [17:27:16] But does software engineer actually have direct server access [17:27:21] @Owen ^ what is the official word on SRE NDA requirements [17:27:26] Anything SRE related would need an NDA [17:27:45] That was an original question of mine, since I'm not in the UK I wouldn't have the ability to physically access the server(s) [17:28:02] so I wasn't sure if that was a blocker. I was told that SE don't actually have server access [17:28:11] SRE would have the ability to access PII, and such and thus would need an NDA, that would be a requirement of any type of place [17:28:12] AmandaCath: SSH access [17:28:17] I got it, I passed it. Why was this resignation made? If Raidarr is going to break the community's trust like that, my next vote for the authorization request would be opposition. [17:28:32] I think no one apart from EMs + the Board has physical access to servers either way [17:28:37] Shell access needs an NDA [17:28:44] how would he break the community's trust by resigning due to personal conflicts? [17:29:16] it's a perfectly good reason and has been done before [17:29:20] Does Software Engineer count as shell access? [17:29:32] The Steward is a manager of the Community anyway. If the steward cannot get along with people, how does he become a steward? [17:29:50] Dynamics change, relationships change, thats how [17:29:58] Pretty sure SE would be granted to sre@, no? [17:30:04] When people are hot headed, it is likely for them to not think twice when talking [17:30:06] The steward should not be at odds with the community at the same time. I think like this. [17:30:09] I didn't have shell access but signed an NDA for email access [17:30:39] He did get along with people. He just had commitments in real life [17:31:12] The resignation was due to time conflicts in real life [17:31:16] not Miraheze [17:31:34] I have problems in real life too. (For example: I have no friends) [17:31:54] You know real life stuffs can affect MH and vice versa [17:31:54] and? [17:32:03] This does need clarification. Would I be required to sign NDA for SE? Or could I opt out of whatever requires it and still do the job effectively? [17:32:05] Sure but it's still a valid reason [17:32:15] Real life, of course, is important, but it is wrong to see the stewardship as such a toy task. [17:32:20] @Owen see this [17:32:39] Yes, I'm sorry raidarr put a paying job and project, along with friends/family, ahead of Miraheze [17:32:45] SE has access to our software which is a risk [17:32:46] I'm confused why this is even a debate [17:32:49] like CreateWiki and ManageWiki [17:32:57] I don't think anyone has seen Stewardship as a toy task [17:33:17] My advice to you, be WC or GR. @AmandaCath [17:33:24] But is that actually private info, since are software code is public anyway? [17:33:25] Stewards and Reddit mods are the most crazy jobs people will work for free [17:33:36] Signing the NDA is unnecessary [17:33:47] I can't see a reason why it would need an NDA - but an EM would be better placed to advise. So far only Shell access requires an NDA [17:33:54] No one trusts anyone anymore. [17:34:08] Who believes whom here? [17:34:20] People who are good today will be bad tomorrow. [17:34:22] ...and Reception is the only EM. So no one to better advise [17:34:45] let's not doomsay [17:35:01] thank you [17:35:13] Me? [17:35:24] Did you say it to me? [17:35:53] Do we still have that IRC feature to store messages to relayed to users who aren't online? [17:35:53] yes [17:36:13] No, when MirahezeBot was taken offline, that went away as well [17:36:53] using @notify will do the same thing via wm-bot [17:37:01] you could also use memos [17:37:29] High five [17:38:23] Your welcome [17:38:39] this is the realities of life, but; no one trusts anyone. [17:38:45] I will let you know when I see Reception123 and I will deliver that message to them [17:38:45] @notify Reception123 please confirm if T10931 Would require me signing an NDA or not. Thanks. [17:39:09] You became GS today, you abused your position tomorrow, get well soon, let the discussion begin. [17:39:55] I want to tear my head out right now [17:39:56] this is insane [17:40:07] I hope Miraheze's fate doesn't get worse [17:40:30] If important people leave MH, it would be a serious downfall. [17:41:52] Not any time soon [17:42:15] hopefully [17:43:00] Did you check their finance? Doesn't look like MH will shutdown unless there was thunderstorm or sort of. [17:43:01] MrBeast made a video watch it lol [17:43:12] you're totally blowing your mind [17:43:25] What is my role in Miraheze? [17:43:39] Editor, viewer [17:44:01] WIki admin? [17:44:05] Editor, Auto-confirmed user, viewer [17:44:37] You can be an admin on your own wiki, but there are some conditions to being here. [17:44:47] [[Meta:Administrators]] [17:44:47] https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Meta:Administrators [17:44:47] [17:45:06] If you want to be an administrator here, you can check this page. [17:45:48] I am not planning to leave to the very end. I will rather let Miraheze die on me then leave. [17:46:10] Whatever happens, I am sticking to Miraheze until the very end. [17:46:42] Thank you very much šŸ„° [17:47:12] @notaracham Can we go to a dm with you? [17:48:40] I am taking care of some things in real life and will be slow to respond. [17:48:57] Feel free to ping questions and I'll get to them when I am able [17:49:11] Again even if we have plenty of Money, the farm will be difficult to maintain when there is a lack of SRE members [17:49:29] You need SRE for a Farm to stay stable [17:51:43] ...and with only one person qualified to process applications, who is currently on break of an undetermined length, don't think there will be new members anytime soon [17:52:06] We really need to make sure that there is more than one active person in every role that currently exists, and any future roles that may be created [17:52:31] this one-person-doing-all-the-work thing creates a single point of failure in a system that is already fragile and stretched thin. We don't need that [17:55:08] The Board can step in to appoint into SRE if absolutely necessary at a point if Reception isn't available and it becomes a problem through absence [17:55:56] The Board was also due to meet to discuss what to do with the 2nd EM position in July [18:06:04] Please can my wikis be deleted: https://meta.miraheze.org/wiki/Stewards%27_noticeboard#Please_Delete_quyraness.miraheze.org_and_theburningprincessnotes.miraheze.org [18:08:06] response will not be quick due to the lack of stewards [18:10:13] Helllo [18:33:48] Hello [18:34:24] stewards will delete your wiki as soon as possible. Do not worry [18:46:18] @AmandaCath Good luck with your wiki creator nomination. I hope you will be selected as a wiki creator like 3 years ago ā¤ļø [19:08:41] Likewise. šŸ± [19:48:03] oh [19:48:09] The Miraheze relay is broken [19:52:40] Test [19:53:01] Relay down [19:56:50] Likely something to do with the API keys which CA/UO controls (they were wanting someone else to take it over) [19:57:50] MacFan4000: I have confirmed that as the cause [19:58:27] well Void or pal-adox need to take care of it in that case [19:58:55] MacFan4000: see discord [19:59:02] The discussion is all there [20:05:12] nice and quiet in here now [20:05:29] Allie: well the other side is very noisy [20:05:43] A Sysadmin who resigned has deleted the relay bot on discord [20:05:54] seems very mature [20:06:45] https://phabricator.miraheze.org/T10943 [20:06:55] new task as a result [20:12:37] Allie: yes it was very mature [20:15:39] @orduin well that's screwed then [20:16:12] I believe the source was public at one point or another, but I don't know how it works, nor do I particularly have the time to work it out at the moment. [20:16:18] Test [20:16:22] Test [20:16:35] A replacement key was created and deployed [20:16:44] Allie, MacFan4000: ^ [20:16:56] @orduin thank you [20:21:40] Is the Replace Text extension no longer supported? [20:22:03] I recall it troublesome [20:22:25] It can be, if you're not careful with it. [20:22:37] Very dangerous if you let somebody with ill intent have access to it. [20:23:11] the ReplaceText doesn't worked with compressed revisions. i think [20:23:49] I made a formatting mistake. Pasted it to 6 pages. No big deal, but it ads up over time. [20:26:34] @orduin might be worth pointing out in #announcements why a lot of messages show as deleted user [20:26:38] From the old bot [20:29:19] Are all messages in #announcements published to following servers? [20:29:54] They are published by a separate action from sending messages [20:31:24] [1/2] But if all, i would recommend bot like this, it will auto publish: [20:31:24] [2/2] [20:31:36] Important names in Miraheze Reserved. [20:31:46] What's going on in Miraheze? [20:32:02] šŸ˜¦ [20:32:03] Things are turbulent [20:32:23] You press a huge button [20:32:57] I hope this turmoil lasts a short time. [20:34:16] [1/2] I know, but if you forgot (or something else) and publish it after few days... Like last message from Void. [20:34:16] [2/2] Also yesterday, "Phabricator is restored" message was published and message before it was not. [20:36:18] We occasionally have server only messages that don't need to be published [20:36:46] Everyone does [20:51:17] Did you do that theme youeself? [21:07:31] No. [21:07:48] https://mysterydungeonwiki.com/wiki/Mystery_Dungeon_Franchise_Wiki [21:08:15] I just re-use the theme from my MDFW, 'cause I'm lazy and couldn't design a good theme/color scheme to save my life. [21:08:27] Black on white and white on black just makes my eyes hurt. [21:08:30] So I go for neutral gray. [21:19:03] I tend towards using black on white or white on dark gray [22:38:47] Steal mine [22:59:32] Damn, that's sexy. [22:59:36] How does it work with color? [23:00:23] Kinda funky how I saw this on the day I was considering playing the Shiren games. [23:01:02] [1/3] BTW, I was the one that sent the original outage announcement for Phab as other folks with perms weren't available to do so. [23:01:02] [2/3] I didn't publish at the time as it appeared to be a short-term issue that didn't need global blasting via publish, wanted to leave final call to those who'd be better equipped to make the determination on duration. [23:01:02] [3/3] If SRE/board folks feel this should have published I'll do so going forward. [23:01:06] The MDFW uses a lot of different themes for the games and major series./ [23:02:01] How did you discover the series? [23:07:10] The Aurora Wasteland Wiki is cumming along nicely. šŸ˜«šŸ‘Œ [23:07:25] I think you misspelled "coming" [23:07:39] It's nice having the author involved. Indie authors seem much more invested in their wikis than those published by monopolies.