[11:17:24] Do you think Cloudflare Turnstile is a good replacement of Wikimedia's captcha? [11:17:44] https://www.cloudflare.com/products/turnstile/ [11:18:23] It works by proof of work, so unlike normal captcha users don't have to classify images [11:20:55] The big issue from the outset is how we deal with loading JS from their sites. Both technically and from a privacy PoV [12:16:15] Update: the ones I've run across in the last week or so have been a user adding the years based on the category on fiwiki for the years they were born in. [12:16:16] [12:16:17] I wouldn't say that they were imported from fiwiki like that user has. (I'd likely mark it as being based on/ the category in fiwiki.) (re @Jan_ainali: Do you have an example?) [12:20:40] How does Cloudflare Turnstile work with accesibility? We still have T6845 unresolved after 15 years. [14:51:21] WMYupik: I believe accessibility support is better since non-interactive challenges need no interaction at all, and interactive ones only requires user to perform a click [14:53:03] The privacy issue is really a valid concern. To comply with the privacy policy a reverse proxy may be required. Not opening source is a problem too, not sure if Cloudflare allows WMF to audit their source code [15:12:11] Diskdance: thank you. It would be good if you could leave a msg about that on the phab tsk. :) [15:36:31] WNYupik: I have created T333770 [15:36:32] T333770: Evaluate Cloudflare Turnstile as a potential alternative to Wikimedia Fancy Captcha - https://phabricator.wikimedia.org/T333770 [15:44:24] Thanks!